ASUS STRIX GTX 970 (Shadow of Mordor VS. Team Fortress 2)

MOPHREAK

Reputable
Nov 2, 2014
2
0
4,510
Those of you that have picked up a new Asus Strix GTX 970, any coil whine issues?

I've tried to cap my framerate with GPU Tweak, I've set V-Sync to ON and/or Adaptive in NVIDIA Control Panel and in-Game, but i'm still getting some coil whine. Not overly loud, but yet it is still audible.

Playing Shadow of Mordor at a Resolution of 1440p (Using DSR) and ultra, i'm averaging 45 - 60 fps. I'm getting coil whine here.

Playing Team Fortress 2, 1080p, my fps doesn't get passed 144fps (I have a 144 Hz monitor), makes sense, as my V-Sync is set to adaptive. BUT, I get NO Coil Whine here.

How is it that i'm getting some nasty coil whine in Shadow of Mordor and not in TF2 at a much larger FPS rate?

Interestingly enough... i started to hear that sound when I launch the Chrome Apps Launcher to Launch Google Chrome.
It would make that sound, but it'll instantly go away.... check out the GPU Tweak Monitor image.
NXoDQVR.png


Any ideas/tips and or suggestions on what to do to fix...?

Is some Coil Whine Normal?

Maybe it'll eventually go away.

My Specs:

i7-4790k i 4.0 GHz
16GB RAM
Asus Z97-Pro WiFi MoBo
Corsair 750W (CX750M) PSU
Asus Strix GTX 970
 
Solution
Hi,

First, I'm not certain this is an issue with "all models" as suggested. I'd like to see an official link if true since what I read suggested it's a known issue with various models of graphics cards.

More:
The reason you get coil whine isn't the frame rate, it's how heavily you are stressing the card. TF2 is being software capped at 144FPS so you aren't pushing the card to the limit.

*For SOM or any other game for which coil whine is an issue here's some things to try:

a) Lower the GPU frequency, at least for now to test. Lock to 1100MHz. You may even try overclocking as well since coil whine is a resonance issue and may be affected within a certain range however I obviously don't have the schematic.

b) Create a VSYNC software...

Brighttail

Reputable
Oct 24, 2014
957
0
5,360
I have seen several posts about coil whine issues coming from the ASUS, not in every card tho. SOme RMA it and come back with no issues tho. I have an asus 770 in my wifes and she plays a lot of games, none you play, but stil graphic intensive with no coil whine so far.
 
Hi,

First, I'm not certain this is an issue with "all models" as suggested. I'd like to see an official link if true since what I read suggested it's a known issue with various models of graphics cards.

More:
The reason you get coil whine isn't the frame rate, it's how heavily you are stressing the card. TF2 is being software capped at 144FPS so you aren't pushing the card to the limit.

*For SOM or any other game for which coil whine is an issue here's some things to try:

a) Lower the GPU frequency, at least for now to test. Lock to 1100MHz. You may even try overclocking as well since coil whine is a resonance issue and may be affected within a certain range however I obviously don't have the schematic.

b) Create a VSYNC software cap:
*Use FRAPS, then tweak the game settings to maintain ABOVE the target refresh rate at least 80% of the time. If you force on Adaptive HALF VSync (per game only, not globally) you'll be effectively synching to 72FPS on a 144Hz monitor.

If that's too high, you could change the monitor into 60Hz mode and either try to synch to 60FPS or even drop down to 30FPS with the Half VSync method.

I use Adaptive VSync for games I know I can't easily maintain 60FPS. In Assassin's Creed Brotherhood for example, regular VSYNC caused major stuttering when I dropped below 60FPS (60Hz monitor) due to the synch mismatch. I couldn't just turn it off like in some games because the Screen Tearing was severe.

So I forced on Adaptive VSync after tweaking to stay above 60FPS most of the time. Later on I noticed too much screen tearing so I dropped a couple settings to minimize that even more (raise average frame rate).

More on COIL WHINE:
It's my understanding that most of the "coil whine" being reported traces back to circuits with INDUCTORS which at specific frequencies start to create a resonance with the card. You can Google that. I bring it up because I'm wondering if physical DAMPENING might help. It's like taking a tuning fork then lightly touching it. You disrupt the vibration and thus the noise.

In the case of GRAPHICS CARDS I'm out of my depth here but perhaps you can ask Asus about whether there's any way to physically dampen coil whine. I suppose you could try touching the card in different spots with your finger in an anti-static bag but I'm not comfortable recommending that.

SUMMARY:
a) experiment with GPU frequency, and
b) create a VSYNC cap
c) Physical dampening of resonance? (ask Asus?)
 
Solution

MOPHREAK

Reputable
Nov 2, 2014
2
0
4,510
Thanks for the tip photonboy...

I will try these tests asap... I've just re-seated the card and noticed that there two gold connectors on the card that are "scratched" at the tips... is this normal??

Bf3wSgL.jpg


sJgXoRq.jpg


Check out the pics...
 
scratched...

Not an issue. If you had any connectivity issues you'd have major errors since the CPU data would be incorrect coming into the card. Also, coil whine has nothing to do with the connection to the computer bus data.

Other:
I doubt this will help, but try grabbing the card (take necessary safety precautions due to heat mainly) during coil whine just to see if the noise changes at all.

I'm pretty sure it won't help as the resonance is likely isolated to a very small area on the circuit board but it's worth trying (safely).