How would you go about setting up this network?

xramirez155

Reputable
Nov 16, 2014
5
0
4,510
Project I am working and I've answered the first question (answer is in red) need help with the last two?

1. You have just begun working as a networking consultant with MTI Technologies Inc.
One of your first tasks is to help troubleshoot a small Ethernet network at a tax preparation office. The backbone of this network consists of six hubs connected in a bus fashion. Three of the hubs service workgroups of 10 workstations each. One of the hubs services two file servers and two shared printers. In anticipation of tax season and a heavier workload, the organization recently upgraded its network from 10BaseT to100BaseT. However, they have not seen any of the performance increases they expected. Before even visiting the firm, what can you suggest as reasons for the less than optimal performance?

If one of the NICs is not capable of 100BASE-TX the entire network will operate on 10BASE-T even if all of the hubs and other NICs are capable of negotiating 100BASE-TX. If there are a large number of transceivers trying to talk at once on a hub-based network they will jam up as packet switched traffic is inherently bursty. There's a limit to the number of repeaters that can be installed between any two hosts on a hub network. There is no such limitation for switches, which is what I would recommend for the company. 10BASE-T allows for 4 repeaters between hosts, but 100BASE-TX allows for only two and only under very strict circumstances. If my initial assessment of the topology is correct, each case involves no less than 3 hubs: one for the workstation group, one for the backbone bus itself, and one for the other workstation group or the servers. This setup would work for 10BASE-T but not 100BASE-TX. Setting up the network described using 100BASE-TX hubs would most likely fail.

2. The network managers at the tax preparation office have followed your advice on reconfiguring the network, and as a result, the network is now running more smoothly. However, they have realized that their Internet connection is too slow. They have been using a dial-up BRI ISDN connection. They want to spend no more than $250 per month on an Internet connection (not including installation fees). They also need a transmission method with fairly good security and a guarantee of adequate throughput during the daytime hours. What solution can you recommend that will offer them the most throughput at this cost? In describing the solution, you will need to include start-up costs as well as monthly operation costs.


3. The Internet connection you have selected for the tax preparation firm is working well. Recently, however, they have learned that their firm will be merging with another firm across town (but also in the city of Chicago). They need a way to connect the two offices. They have heard about using data lines to carry telephone conversations, and they are interested in adding that to their requirements for the data connection. Also, although they want the connection to be reliable, they are not willing to spend the extra money for an extremely fault tolerant network. On the other hand, now that they have merged with another firm, they have the means to pay up to $2000 per month for a connection. What solution do you suggest?
 
This is a outrageously old question. Almost everything is completely invalid to even think about If you can actually even find a place that sells a hub I would like to see it. This is more than 10yrs old. This is almost as bad as the old question about if you need straight or cross cable.

You would be lucky to find people that even know what BRI connection is. Nobody even thinks to install those. Even the worst dsl line can do faster than 128k that a bri maxes out at.

The main issue you have is the pricing is way out of date compared to what you can really get.

In the last example depending on the actual locations you could likely get a protected fiber connection that could run up to 10g for 2k/month within most major cities. A protected fiber ring is the absolute best connection you can ever find. I know we pay only about $1300 for a connection that goes 10km and runs at 1g....we could run at 10g but they don't want to spend the money for the equipment but the fiber can do it.

Still there is no way to even think to answer questions like this. Anyone who has ever ordered a connection into a building knows that there is no way to even predict the costs. If the building is already on a number of telcos fiber rings...ie the building is lit you have lots of options. If you must install the demark in a empty building it greatly increases your costs.
 

xramirez155

Reputable
Nov 16, 2014
5
0
4,510


Thanks I actually was able to complete the project with all the correct answers, we actually had a discussion (my classmates) on just how obsolete the stuff they are teaching us is.. like Hubs really? lol.