Intel HD GT1 vs. GeForce GT520

ic3b3rg

Honorable
Oct 28, 2013
3
0
10,510
I have a client who currently has a Dell computer with an i5-3550 which includes the integrated Intel HD GT1. In gutting a few other computers he has he found a Zotac GT520 card and wants to know if this will give him any performance benefits over what is built into his computer. I told him I would look into it and am not having much luck finding a direct comparison. Thoughts?
 
Solution
In theory it would give a performance boost, but in practice it is not worth the extra power draw. Intel graphics are sufficient for everything except 3d games and high end computing. If your client is doing either of those, he needs more than a GT520. If he is not doing those things, he wouldn't notice the difference.

A dedicated card can help by possibly freeing up system memory. Since the card has its own video memory, the system would not need to share main memory for graphics processing. It could also improve performance by allowing the CPU to run cooler. If the integrated gpu is disabled, the cpu cores can have more thermal headroom to run at their turbo boost. Of course, using a dedicated gpu will add more heat to the system as...
In theory it would give a performance boost, but in practice it is not worth the extra power draw. Intel graphics are sufficient for everything except 3d games and high end computing. If your client is doing either of those, he needs more than a GT520. If he is not doing those things, he wouldn't notice the difference.

A dedicated card can help by possibly freeing up system memory. Since the card has its own video memory, the system would not need to share main memory for graphics processing. It could also improve performance by allowing the CPU to run cooler. If the integrated gpu is disabled, the cpu cores can have more thermal headroom to run at their turbo boost. Of course, using a dedicated gpu will add more heat to the system as a whole so performance increases would depend on the cooling setup.
 
Solution

justaguywithagun

Distinguished
Dec 14, 2009
430
0
18,960


i think you nailed everything right on the head. also, this
i see the intel hd4600 ranking rather high...only passmark in this link though
 

ic3b3rg

Honorable
Oct 28, 2013
3
0
10,510
Thanks everyone for the input. I will let him know that it will have minimal impact on his graphics situation but may help with RAM. He isn't into gaming but does want to add on two additional monitors so I will go ahead and install the card so that he doesn't have to buy display port adapters and to help out with the fact he only has 2GB or RAM.