I personally don't like liquid cooling. I know some guys love it, but myself, I'll choose air every time. If it can't be done using air cooling, it probably exceeds what's reasonably safe for the chip anyhow. GPU's are the exception. I know air coolers can be real estate hogs but they work, you always know if they are cooling or not (Unlike pumps), they don't ever leak (Unless you abuse the heat pipes and poke holes in them somehow, or do what one client did and snip the tops of the heat pipes off so the case cover would clear. Heh. I don't know why it doesn't cool.) I like the D14. Too big for my current rig but when I get a full tower case again I'll definitely either take my D14 off the shelf or maybe get a D15. I think the D14 is fine though. The D15 just seems like overkill for a few degrees difference.
Anyhow, sorry that didn't work out for you but hopefully the Noctua will treat you better.