Choosing between AT&T & Verizon

spdragoo

Splendid
Ambassador
OK, we're looking to finally go with smartphones -- we don't need the smartphones per se, but my wife is tired of the lack of connection on her Tracfone fliphone.

Since we already have iPod touches, and she has an iPad Air for her job (professor at a local community college), we decided we're going with iPhones. Haven't decided which ones yet, but leaning towards 5S (prefer 32GB over the 16GB) or the 6 (not the plus, probably just 16GB). We also eliminated T-Mobile & Sprint from the selection -- although T-Mobile's prices seem to be the best, their coverage areas aren't as large; Sprint supposedly has great customer service, but my brother-in-law had no access whenever he would go on base.

That leaves the big 2: AT&T & Verizon. Now, I'm looking over their pricing structures & options they have available. The biggest issue I'm running into, however, is the way Verizon's cart works; even though they advertise their "More Everything" family plans with multiple devices and indicating that you can choose your smartphones with their Edge program, the actual online cart will only allow 1 device on the Edge plan at a time.

In any case, though, aside from price, are there any particular reasons to pick AT&T over Verizon, or vice versa? They both have unlimited talk/text, so that doesn't matter. And while the majority of my in-laws have AT&T already (brother-in-law & his wife have iPhones, other brother-in-law has Android, & sister-in-law & her husband have "lower-end" phones -- they're not Android/Apple/Windows smartphones, but they're more than just a flipphone), unlimited talk/text means we don't have to be on the same network to contact them.

And yes, I know that AT&T is planning on introducing rollover data on Monday (1/25), something that Verizon is apparently not working on yet. However, considering that for apparenlty an extra $10 or so per month over their "base" plans both AT&T & Verizon offer 10GB/month of shared data, rollover is nice but not necessarily the dealbreaker.

What I'm mainly looking for is, which one is a) generally less expensive (i.e. fewer hidden costs on your bills), b) more reliable, & c) better to work with for customer service?
 
Solution
Well, decided to go with AT&T over the weekend. Basically, it came down to a couple of things:
-- both were about the same price for the 10GB/month plan, but we don't think we need quite that much (we plan on relying mostly on Wi-Fi for our Internet/apps).
-- Even without my employer's discount, AT&T 6GB plan was cheaper than Verizon's 4GB plan (both of which are the next step down from the 10GB plans)
-- Having that nice 15% discount (although my account says 17%, so bonus!) on top, plus the rollover potential, made it that much better.

And we went with the 64GB iPhone 6 models -- definitely like having the storage space, don't need the larger Plus -- but we went with the 2-year contract. It was cheaper than the up-front on the...

tranadra

Reputable
Jan 22, 2015
12
0
4,520
I've been a customer with Verizon for ten years, so your mileage may vary as a new customer, but they actually work with me to lower prices on bills. It seems like every time I visit the brick store, they modify account so that it's a little bit cheaper, more data/minutes, etc.

In my part of the world, AT&T has bad service / reception, I don't know as I've never had a carrier other than Verizon.

Look at a third party coverage map, (don't go to one from Verizon or AT&T) and see what coverage is like in your area before you decide, as every area varies.

Maybe this wasn't very apparent online, but you get rebates on your bill if you go with EDGE. We have three people on or plan with EDGE, so we actually don't pay for our data, and we get 15G a month. I get a discount through my employer (your wife might as well since she works at a comm coll) so once again your mileage may vary.

As far as the phones, I would recommend getting something larger than 16G, as that's simply too small. 64G is the next size up on a iP6, and it's only a couple of bucks a month on the bill if you use EDGE.

I've been very happy with my service with Verizon, so I would highly recommend them.

HTH
 

OriginalCadaver

Reputable
May 24, 2014
596
0
5,360
So you're going to get ripped off with either. Verizon or ATT will charge you regardless if you use the data or not, then heavily penalize you if you go over your limits. If you don't mind buying a phone out of pocket, you can go with a no contract deal and save tons of money. I'm not sure if Verizon or ATT offer that, give them a call or stop at a kiosk and ask at least.
 

spdragoo

Splendid
Ambassador
OriginalCadaver, they do both offer that option -- AT&T has it as one of the 2 options where they discount the per-line "access charge" (the other being their "Next" payment plan option); Verizon also has it available, but they don't discount the charges.

tranadra, definitely myself would prefer the larger sizes -- it's why we picked the midrange iPod Touch (32GB) instead of the "bargain" one. And yeah, an extra $100 for another 16GB (5S) or 48GB (6) of internal storage is definitely worth it.
 

spdragoo

Splendid
Ambassador
Well, decided to go with AT&T over the weekend. Basically, it came down to a couple of things:
-- both were about the same price for the 10GB/month plan, but we don't think we need quite that much (we plan on relying mostly on Wi-Fi for our Internet/apps).
-- Even without my employer's discount, AT&T 6GB plan was cheaper than Verizon's 4GB plan (both of which are the next step down from the 10GB plans)
-- Having that nice 15% discount (although my account says 17%, so bonus!) on top, plus the rollover potential, made it that much better.

And we went with the 64GB iPhone 6 models -- definitely like having the storage space, don't need the larger Plus -- but we went with the 2-year contract. It was cheaper than the up-front on the no-contract option, & my wife prefers spending a little more up-front rather than pushing our monthly bill so high.
 
Solution