Best CPU upgrade path for a 1366 socket user (i7-920)

VicVega1

Reputable
Jan 10, 2015
317
0
4,860
Hi, everybody!
I've beed recently wondering about upgrading my CPU and I'm not quite sure which way to go. Hope you can help.
My current setup:
CPU: i7-920 overclocked to 3,8GHz
Mobo: MSi Eclipse SLI
RAM: 16GB DDR3 1600
GPU: Gigabyte HD7970
PSU: 750W PC Power and Cooling
My PC is used mostly for gaming. I think it's still a pretty decent setup and it allows me to enjoy even performance hungry games at high settings, but I feel the CPU is bottlenecking it, even overclocked. And the thought that I'm not getting the best out of it is bugging me to be frank :)


I'll list 3 options I've come up with:

1. Keep the i7-920 for a year or so, till the dust comes down on the X99 systems. then sell out all my crap and get a completely new rig
pros: having a 100% up to date rig
cons: having to live with an insufficent, propably bottlenecked system for a whole year

2. Sell the i7-920 and replace it with something like a Xeon X5660 or X5650 and overclock it trying to get the best out of my current setup for a year or two
pros: having a better CPU with the least amount of money involved in the upgrade
cons: investing in an aging technology
concerns: are server CPUs good for gaming? will it work well with non-ECC RAM?

3. Sell the i7-920 with the mobo and get a 1150 socket board like for example Gigabyte GA-Z97MX-Gaming with a i7 4790k CPU (using the current GPU, PSU and RAM)
pros: significant upgrade for up to 3 years and for a lot less money than buying a completely new rig; Broadwell upgradeable
cons: still quite a big investment for not so new parts

Which of those seems to be most reasonable? or maybe there is another option?
 

VicVega1

Reputable
Jan 10, 2015
317
0
4,860
I actually have been looking for those and the 980s, but they're very hard to get in Europe. Plus a new one is almost as much as a Gigabyte GA-Z97MX-Gaming mobo and an i7 4790k combined. Whereas used are twice as much as the Xeon X5660.
 

Selected

Reputable
Jan 22, 2015
21
0
4,510
What did you go for? Having the same situation as you now :)

Specs:
Asus P6T deluxe V2 1366 chipset motherboard
Intel Core i7-950 (Watercooled)
AMD Radeon HD 5970 Powercolor (Watercooled)
Revodrive 120 GB SSD PCI-e
Corsair dominator GT 10 Gb (2Gb died for some reason)
 

Cryio

Distinguished
Oct 6, 2010
881
0
19,160
Dunno about server CPUs.

Since you have 1st gen Core i7, Intel's Skylake CPUs were basically made for you.

But yeah, even AMD's CPUs, like FX 8350 and up are faster than your 1st gen i7. Buy whatever man. AMD's Piledriver or Intel's Haswell/Broadwell/Skylake.
 

VicVega1

Reputable
Jan 10, 2015
317
0
4,860
I went with option number one. Reason for this was my PC still being able to run games in highest settings (or almost highest). Reference point was The Witcher 3 - I'm playing in uber (or ultra) settings (without nVidia's hairworks), in 1920x1200 res and it runs smooth. After upgrading to Win10 it even runs nicely with hairworks on (not all the time though). Shadow of Mordor, FarCry 4, GTAV, Alien Isolaton, Witcher 3 - all run suprisingly nice in highest settings, so I'm waiting for the prices on Skylake to drop a little bit and will make a fresh Skylake build at the end of this year. I was thinking about getting another 7970 and crossfiring it with my current card, but there's no point in investing in my PC, since it's doing well.
So bottom line, I'm not doing nothing with my current rig and putting all my eggs in the Skylake basket at the end of the year and that is my advice to you as well.
Buying anything, like Cryio said is not a good way to go in my mind. If you've waited so long with an upgrade, get the best thing that's on the market. Of course you have to consider your budget. You could just get a better graphics card (r9 290x for example) and get along with your current rig for a year or a bit longer, but I would much more prefer trying out new technologies - Skylake, DDR4, HBM VRAM etc.

 

VicVega1

Reputable
Jan 10, 2015
317
0
4,860
Didn't think about it to be honest. Well nevermind anyway - I got a really nice deal on an ASUS Z170-A motherboard and DDR4 memory so I went with Skylake.
Another thing worth considering when thinking about an upgrade - if you wait too long your old parts maybe worthless. My i7-920, the Eclipse SLI mobo, DDR3 RAM, 7970 - all sold within an hour after posting an ad tops! And for really good prices.