PC won't start with graphics card connected, had faulty PSU, but old working PSU gives same result

sauronnikko

Reputable
Oct 23, 2014
6
0
4,510
Hi. Two months ago, sometimes, when I turned on my PC, the fans from my graphics card (an EVGA NVIDIA 780 GTX 6 GB) would spin at the highest speed, and the card would not output display. This happened seldomly for the first few weeks, then it became frequent. Every single time the fix was to clear the BIOS CMOS.

However, today my machine just wouldn't turn on. I tried clearing the CMOS to no avail. I took my computer to a technician who told me my PSU (a Corsair RM850) was damaged. The PC actually turned on when disconnecting the graphics card, but then it would shut down sometime afterwards. This also happened using the PSU in another machine.

I RMA'd my PSU, and I'm expecting a new one in one or two weeks. However, when I returned home I installed an old PSU I had (Thermaltake TR2 700W) which used to work with my PC and it too didn't turn on the machine when I left the graphics card. If I removed the graphics card, it started. I even put an old GPU (a Nvidia 680 GTX) and everything worked ok.

I'm afraid my GPU died, that perhaps the PSU killed it. It seems weird to me that using a different PSU which actually was the previous one installed in the same PC doesn't work now and exhibits the same kind of behaviour the last one had (can turn on the PC without the graphics card, can't turn on with the graphics card)

Is it ok to be worried about my GPU?
 

sauronnikko

Reputable
Oct 23, 2014
6
0
4,510


But if it were dead, shouldn't its fans not spin whenever inserted to the PCI-e slot but unconnected to the power supply? Is it normal for a broken graphics card to spin its fans? Also, is it actually possible that it prevents powering on the system? I'd have thought it would just not display anything
 

pjwilliamson

Honorable
Jul 5, 2013
33
0
10,540
Seems to me the fans would run because they are running on the power of the mobo it doesn't necessarily need circuits to run the fans, but I could be mistaken. I just see no one else attempted a response so I thought I would give it a shot. I had a perfectly good graphics card that would not run in my older HP even when I upgraded my PSU and CPU, it just would not work no display no matter what I did and would stop in it tracks, the computer had power but that was it, so I had to resort to the onboard graphics and install the card in a newer HP and it works fine and I also moved the psu over to the new machine it is a Thermaltake TR2 500W. Do you have another computer you can try the card in?
 

TRENDING THREADS