HyperX Cloud 2 vs Audio Technica AD700x vs Other Headphones For CS:GO

ruledarkman

Reputable
Oct 20, 2014
26
0
4,540
INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND

The title says it all. This is my third question on Tom's hardware and all of them have been in regards to the same thing. My first one, nearly half a year ago was me finally showcasing my new gaming computer build. That was when I fell in love with Tom's Hardware and its amazing community, as my build was revolutionized by the great help I got.

The next post is closer to this one, and it was only a few weeks ago, what headphones to get. That post is since then dead, and I have narrowed my choices to two pairs of headphones/headsets for positional cues in CS:GO. I also have some follow-up questions I didn't ask in my last post. Any other headphone recommendations are accepted, but try to answer the questions I put at the bottom with regards to them and give me reasons why they are viable as an option compared to these two.

First I will describe my current stance and thoughts on these two headphones, and then ask my questions and your opinions on which of these is better. As always thank you to everyone who comments on this or even reads it attempting to help. Try to answer questions in numbered format but also put all of your own thoughts as I am starving for information. I wanna make an informed decision. Thank you!

MY STANCE

First, the HyperX Cloud 2 headset. I have heard great things about these but my question is will the surround sound help me in game to get positional cues. I want to get the maximum I can get out of CS:GO, and since I have heard about the terrible sound quality of CS:GO I was wondering whether these would be just as good as their audio technica opponent? I am sure that these are more comfortable, and though look is a minor factor, these look far better than the AD700x and it's nice to see something pleasant next to your computer. You see pros in CS:GO always using headsets such as the steelseries siberia v2 and kraken pros and these are not even usually as good as the Hyper X Cloud 2. Is it even worth it to spend the extra buck for the AD700x in a game like CS:GO? Not to mention the clouds are better for music and movies. So, if the sound is the same, then these are the choice.

Next, the audio technica AD700x headphones, these are renowned as the best for sound cues but apparently their base is non-existent. Now, some of my concerns. I am only 14 years old, and as a result, have a fairly small head, I have heard some complaints about small heads not fitting on these. Also, I am not an audiophile, and CS:GO is my heart and soul, but how bad exactly is the music and movie quality sound. I understand that the bass is not as good as other headphones, but is it absolutely terrible? If it is that will influence my decision as my computer is used for netflix and youtube a fair bit. I will be using an Asus Xonar DG and a Zalman clip on mic with this.

QUESTIONS

1. IN CS:GO, I CANNOT STRESS THIS ENOUGH THIS QUESTION ONLY APPLIES TO CS:GO, will there be any difference in hearing the positional cues between these 2 headphones? As the sound stage in CS is considered absolutely terrible and extremely limited, is it possible that the Hyper X Cloud 2 will be the same?

2. When people describe the AD700x as absolutely amazing for gaming, is this just using it as the default stereo headset with no modifications or anything? I know people say that 7.1 is a gimmick (I'd also like your thoughts on that) but if I opened these the day I got them, plugged them in and turned on CS:GO, would that be the same sound most people describe as "legendary" for positional cues in CS:GO. It is still hard for me to believe how stereo headphones can be that good for positional cues so I would like some confirmation.

What settings do people usually use with it? Try not to make it overly complicated with hardware speak as I am new to this, but should I use that dolby application I heard you can download? What about that free razer surround sound program making every stereo headphones surround sound, does that make it better? Should I have the 7.1 in the Asus Xonar DG turned on even though the AD700x is stereo. This also applies to the cloud headphones, would those programs help? So far, if I had the AD700x headphones right now all I would know to do would be to download the Razer free surround sound program, turn it on, go into my sound card settings, and turn on the surround sound there too in the hopes of having these two things give it more of a "positional" sound. I would also try different options in CS:GO as listed below. What more could I do? What shouldn't I do? Are my thoughts on the right path?

Furthermore on options, which ones should I use ingame in CS:GO. I am assuming for the HyperX cloud I should use the 5.1 and snd_legacy_1 setting since they are surround. But for the AD700x, should I use the headphones setting in CS:GO with snd_legacy set to 0 or should I still have the surround sound settings to make it give a more "positional" sound.

3. Obviously the Asus Xonar DG is better than any USB sound card in headsets. That being said, do I have to use the USB sound card in the Hyper X Cloud 2 to be able to use its 7.1 audio?

4. With my pretty small average 14 year old head, will the AD700x fall off my head? Will it be uncomfortable as some people have described?

5. Just how bad is the bass for the AD700x? Will it just make listening to anything terrible and artificial, or are the people saying it is bad meaning it as a small problem to an otherwise amazing pair of headphones that they must mention because everything else is great?

6. The circle of hearing in CS:GO is big, I mean like, if there is no sound around you, people such as Warowl (who uses Sennheiser HD598s, stereo headphones) can hear almost half way across the map. Keep in mind that I also want to be able to hear far away from me to gain info on where they are going, not just when they are around a corner. I am sure both of these headphones can hear people who are behind you around a corner about to shoot you. But these are not too different in price ($30 if I include the need to get a zalman clip on microphone for the AD700x), so which one would give me the best hearing I can possibly get? This is really like an indepth version of question #1, asking if these would both give me, the maximum potential sound I can get. If it damn near unnoticeable, then it doesn't REALLY matter, but mention it anyway.

7. Answering the questions above and taking them into consideration, which one is better for primarily CS:GO, but also things like netflix and youtube in your own opinion?

Thank you for reading and as the answers come in, I may ask some other questions. I really appreciate all the help I get! I am always open to new suggestions. Like I said, a lot of pros use the steelseries siberia v2 and I have also heard alot about logitech headsets such as the g35. If you can recommend a different headset such as those and give me good reasons as why it is as solid a choice as the 2 this thread is mainly about, I am completely open-minded! I have also heard amazing things about the plantronics 780s, but don't know anything about them as they have completely skipped my research, so if anybody knows something about them, from what I've heard about its awards and great sound, it might be a viable option if I hear more about it. Overall just thank you to everyone and try to help me out :)
 
1. It is possible. If the game is bad at it, the audio technica might be better, even 200% better than they hyperx, but if the soundstage is non-existant, 200% of 0 is still 0.
If you dont test it yourself, you will never know (different people have different subjective experience when it comes to sound).

2.As i already described in your previous post, 7.1 and stereo in headphone is esentially the same, as your brain interprets position based on two factors alone:
Delay from sound reaching ear 1 and ear 2, and volume of the sound reaching ear 1 and ear 2. So yes, stereo and 7.1 in terms of headphones is esentially the same, and what matters is the quality of the sound and the soundcard/drivers.

3. Dont know, it should be in the headphone manual.

4. This is subjective, so no way to predict. (thats why you should try them first).

5. Its not about "Bad", but shy. It will not be a strong bass. It will not be there often. It wont WOW you. Thats why they are good for CS:GO, because when a granade goes off it wont overshadow the sound of everything else.
This however will make the headphone sound boring and un-exiting.

6- Id go for the 598, since they are better overall headphones in my view (thou a touch worse in positional cues).
The problem with the AT is that it will be good only for CS GO while sennheisers are going to be good for everything.

7- No clue, I have not heard the Audio technica personally (thats why I suggest you do it yourself and then decide).
 

ruledarkman

Reputable
Oct 20, 2014
26
0
4,540
CATS_PAW, WELCOME BACK! :). Thank you so much for trying to help my stupid brain put technology together again! You pretty much answered everything, as you did last time, except the questions with the options which is understandable considering you don't have CS:GO.

The sennheiser 598s were my original front runner, but as many people say, are a very high priced option so I looked elsewhere first. They are still one of the best options and I am just researching on whether the sound is worth the extra money.

I wanted to ask you where I can try out these headphones, will any store just let me put them on if I ask, and where can I actually try them out in game if at all possible?

Thank you so much for once again answering. Though you probably deserve it for your once again well-thought out answer, I will not give you the solution as I want more answers on all questions to get a wide-range of opinions, and mostly to get the answer to my question about what options to use with stereo headphones. As in, whether to use any surround sound options I can or just leave it as it is. From the feeling I got from you, it was just to leave it alone as the sound would be the same. Perhaps the answer is to just toy around with it when I get it as messing with the options is free.

If you do look back on the post, perhaps you can answer on which one you would choose based on only the Cloud 2 and the AD700x, though your recommendation of the HD598s is weighing heavily on my mind.
 
Dont worry on solution, its only an EGO-booster anyway :D.

Hm... any store? No.
But most actually should. Make sure you bring a mp3 player with you that has good quality recordings (I can send you some youtube links for that), and also recording from different types (one where there is a lot of bass, other where there are a lot of voices, otehr where there is a lot of high frecuency plays, etc).

Also please note that when you hear the HD598, you will be hearing it at around 90% of its potential (to get the remaning 10% you might need a amp for the headphones, but we can talk about that other time).

Stores usually will let you try headphones (especially those that specialize in audio, so not wallmart, but a store with only audio gear in it). But this is a hit and miss, its not possible for me to determine a priori where you can get to test headphones for sure.

EDIT:
By the way, the reason I dont suggest the Audio technica is because you might be very dissapointed when you want to just listen to some music or watch a action movie after playing cs go.
Also, if you do play other games from time to time, that small bass might be something you wont be happy with.
I tried the HD598 myself a few times and I was always happy with it.
Finally, your brain WILL take some time to adjust to the new signature of the headphone. You can expect (and I am very serious when I say this) anywhere between 20 and 80% of what you would say is sound improvement after you had the headphones for some time.
It wont actually improve by that much, but you will get more used to it, making it "sound" better.
 

ruledarkman

Reputable
Oct 20, 2014
26
0
4,540
Hmmm, ok and what would you say about the HyperX cloud 2, if you know anything about that.

The options thing is my main confusion, say I got the stereo 598s, would downloading the razer surround sound freeware, and enabling 7.1 sound in my soundcard and CS:GO make it sound better or worse? Would it try to make it sound more positional, or mess up and just make it sound weird?
 
I have not heard the HyperX cloud 2, but there is a very clear consensus in the audiophile comunity that headsets are of lower quality and overpriced compared to headphones (there are many reasons behind this, like branding, marketing, sponsorship costs that have to be covered in the price of a headset).
razer surround works with any headphones (it bypasses your common drivers and uses its own for positional audio).

Personally, Razer for me was slightly better than stereo, but the difference was very minimal, so I uninstalled it. The more drivers in your PC, the higher the chance that they will interact negatively with each other.

I suggest you simply find a shop close to you where they have the sennheiser, call them and ask if they would allow you to compare the headphone to yours (it usually takes 3 minutes to know if its worth it, so you wont really be taking a lot of their time).
Bring your headphones and compare them to the sennheisers. Hell, I even brought my laptop to one of those shops when I was comparing an amplifier :D.
 

ruledarkman

Reputable
Oct 20, 2014
26
0
4,540
Though I am looking at headphones >$100, my budget is not infinite. So how much does the amp improve sound in the sennheiser hd598s and how much would I have to spend on a good one. Would it make a good difference in CS:GO, or in any game?
 
Let me put it this way, an amp is something you do not need right away. Think of it as a great way to slightly improve your headphones.
In fact, your asus xonar already has an amp, the only problem is that it is inside your PC, where there is a lot of interference.
Test the sennheiser headphones first. If you really like them and buy them, leave the amp for later.

The cheapest good quality amp I know of is Schiit magni, normally pair with a DAC (Digital to analog Converter) called Modi (http://schiit.com/).
It might seem like a cheap toy but its not only great in terms of price/performance ratio, but is as good of a system as you will ever need with those headphones.

That beeing said, leave that for later, the improvement as I said wont be huge at this point, the biggest difference comes from the headphones.

*As a point of reference, my headphones, that need a decent extra power then the sennheiser HD598 to sound good sound "as I think they should" from the amplifier I use. When I use them with only my mp3, they still sound better than anything else I got, but I miss the amp.

Let me explain in short what the amp actually does:
Point one is adds volume. This is rather obvious. This also means you have to be careful not to get sound too loud to hurt your ears, or to even damage the headphones.

Point two, is it adds dynamic resolution and speed. In general, if your headphones want to make a high pitch sound after a bass note, they need more power than if the two notes are very similar. If you dont have an amp, the transition will sound worse, as well as slower. Think of it like trying to jump from standing up position and trying to jump from kneeling or sitting.
The amount of power that the headphone needs to to make sure it sound as it is supposed to, is a lot higher than its nominal power requirement, but I dont want to confuse you too much with numbers, so I wont go into much detail here, unless you want to know.

So, in more... simple terms, what does it mean to have an amp vs not have an amp? with the amp the sound will feel a bit more real, and have a bit more power/weight/body.... hard to put this into words. Without the amp, it will feel like the sound is slightly more away... like behind curtains, or a thin wall

(bare in mind this is subjectively, this means that the first time you hear the headphones, you wont get that feeling. You will only get it after you have tried them with an amp, and then go back without an amp. It is always relative to something else, never objective).
 

ruledarkman

Reputable
Oct 20, 2014
26
0
4,540
Thanks again, this information really puts the 598s back in my mind as a choice. I'd still really like to hear some other opinions, especially from some CS:GO players who could answer why pros seem to use sub par headphones. I am honestly at a loss for what to choose so I think I will get some more opinions from this thread and then try to test all 3 of these headphones out at some stores. Thanks for the help :D
 

ruledarkman

Reputable
Oct 20, 2014
26
0
4,540
Well now I am mostly between audio-technica and sennheiser, I think what I will do is go to a store and try to listen to some music with both. I know they will both be amazing in CS, so I will see whether the bass is truly too flat and shy. Like I said I am not an audiophile, so I might end up choosing the audio technica.

One thing still weighing heavily on my mind is that I commented on a video of the youtuber warowl, who is a very good CS player with sennheiser 598s, and he said that he used those headphones because they are open-back, so he can hear himself when he commentates, but that they are overkill for CS:GO. If the sennheiser are overkill, then so are the audio technica.

I am really at a loss :D, I hope more people see this soon.
 
Hmm, overkill? Yes in a way they are.
We are talking about very good headphones that are simply better than what you need for CS GO.
That however does not mean they wont be better :D. I suggest you google the term diminishing returns to understand why some people consider overkill others consider perfect.
But when you listen to them you will know better.