ASUS Crosshair V Formula POST problem

stacj

Distinguished
Nov 5, 2011
19
0
18,510
Hello everyone,

My ASUS Crosshair V Formula has served it's time and has been a great board while it lasted. I spoke with ASUS and if there was still a warranty on it (expired 5 days before mobo death), ASUS would RMA the board for servicing.

The board goes through the POST process but stops after checking the CPU, leaving the mobo's CPU POST LED red and goes no further; no beeps or a BIOS screen either. Every fan is also spinning.

ASUS put me through a barrage of troubleshooting steps including but not limited to: swapping 3 compatible CPU's; changing PSU's; resetting CMOS via jumper and battery; swapping RAM sticks with different slots; taking everything out of the case and using a non-conductive surface to test on with a rinse and repeat of the prior steps. The end result is still the same as before.

Now, instead of just recycling the board, I would like to learn why this board failed. I want the knowledge to be able to test for issues such as this in the future. Perhaps I can get lucky by doing a re-flow to prolong its life as I have done with some laptop GPU's or even replace a bad component, etc...

I have equipment to test with but I do not know exactly where to start. I went to ITT for electronics but didn't finish due to a car accident and I honestly have forgotten a lot since that was 17 years ago. Hehe, I still have my formulas cheat sheet to figure out voltages and such. Also, soldering is not a problem as I still do that from time to time. I have another desktop to use so this is just going to be a hobby project.

Anyways, if anyone has advice or even a link to a thread/site that could be a guide, I would be grateful. Thanks for any and all advice in advance.
 

Andrew Murdoch

Honorable
Mar 16, 2013
686
0
11,160
This is a good article. If it had anything to do with the VRM this will give you the information you need to assess.

http://www.overclockers.com/forums/showthread.php/679903-About-VRMs-amp-Mosfets-Motherboard-Safety-with-125W-TDP-processors

I have personal experience with one of the aforementioned items: "Try testing the motherboard with the 24-pin plugged in but without the 4-pin/8-pin CPU power plug. This is the ultimate dealbreaker; if the motherboard only boots when CPU power plug is unplugged (though it obviously won't POST), you sir have a VRM failure on your hands."

I had a mobo die by VRM failure and it took my 2500k with it. That bit of info was the most important for me before rma.
 

BadBoyGreek

Distinguished
If you've swapped every component imaginable, tried different RAM slot configs, replacing the CMOS battery etc., then it could be some other random component on the board that's failed like a capacitor, something on the chipset, voltage regulator and so on. Some things are not intended to be user serviceable and there's only so much you can do to troubleshoot.

Mobo makers have special diagnostic tools which give them more in depth failure and logging info, not to mention they have spare parts on hand for testing other random failures. Unless you want to get into soldering and removing chips etc. from the board, it sounds like you've done all the right things otherwise :)
 

stacj

Distinguished
Nov 5, 2011
19
0
18,510


Yes indeed on that being a good article with even more useful links in it. Thanks for that link! I am certainly going to test for a VRM failure.



I do not mind soldering or replacing anything since this is going to be something to learn with. I may not have the advanced equipment that ASUS owns but I still wish to try and obtain some knowledge since that is never a bad thing. :)

Thank you both for responding to my post as I do appreciate any help.

 

Andrew Murdoch

Honorable
Mar 16, 2013
686
0
11,160
There is also the possibly of a bricked bios. That would allow it to turn on, do a beep but then nothing else. If you contact your mobo manufacturer you might be able to request a replacement bios chip. Asrock recently did it for me for an old g41-m gs board!
 

stacj

Distinguished
Nov 5, 2011
19
0
18,510


I haven't had any extra time to check this out but I didn't want to leave this thread unanswered. I will post my results as soon as I have some "free" time.
Thanks for taking the time to post this suggestion as well. :)