WD My Passport Ultra beeps irregularly and doesn't get recognized after short fall

stkl93

Reputable
Mar 24, 2015
3
0
4,510
Hello guys,

as the title suggests, my 1TB WD MyPassport Ultra seems to have developed some connection issues after a short drop (max half a metre/1'7").

When I connect it to my PC I get the usual Win 7 connection sound but it doesn't show up in Win Explorer.
In the task bar however I can "safely disconnect" the drive. When I access 'devices and printers' in the control panel I can see the WD and can access the properties where it is displayed as working flawlessly.
I can also see it in the device manager under drives where it also seems to have no problems.
The disk management does not display it as working, it only shows it as an unknown not initialised HDD. Initialisation does not work and I also don't really know what that does or means.

I tried to listen to the sounds the HDD makes and they seem to be quite normal. I don't have klicking or scratching sounds but a rather smooth spinning sound. I however can't really hear any head movement compared to other harddrives I subsequently listened to.
Something weird is that it irregularly (every 5 minutes or so) stops with a beep and then starts spinning again.

I cannot access any data as it doesn't show up in Win Explorer. WD lifeguard diagnostics does not recognise the drive and Recuva doesn't help either.

Any suggestions as to what might be wrong? Would open up the case and looking at the USB 3.0 connectors help? Would the freezer thing help?
My priorities are data recovery and not necessarily getting the thing fully working again.

Appreciate your help :)
 
Solution
Your hard drive is most likely dead. You can try opening it up. It is possible that the usb connector was dislodged from the actual drive, but that is very unlikely. The freezer won't help (It won't hurt either).

stkl93

Reputable
Mar 24, 2015
3
0
4,510


Sh*t...
Unfortunately no backup and some personal pictures. Still nothing worth 1000€...
Well, I'll see what opening it up might do.

I think this is a really poor example for the WD build quality. A drop from shorter than 50cm and this kind of irreperable damage leaves me a bit speechless.
 
The laws of physics are against you. Even a short fall, if it lands at just the right angle or with the drive spinning can cause a failure. There really is nothing that can be done and still keep drives both portable and affordable. You can't really fault WD for not doing the impossible. If you've got $500, you can buy a 1TB SSD, put it into an external enclosure, and throw it around as much as you like.
 
Hi there stkl93,

Unfortunately, it seems that you will need some professional data recovery help in order to retrieve the data. :(
Taking the drive out of the enclosure will not work as the drive is hardware encrypted. This means that you will not be able to access the data if the drive is out of the enclosure.
If only the enclosure got damaged from the fall(not the HDD itself), you can try attaching the drive internally -> format -> use it in a third party enclosure or internally.

In case you decide to go with data recovery, you can check WD's Data Recovery Partners out: http://products.wdc.com/support/kb.ashx?id=4TCZoD

Cheers,
D_Know_WD :)