Windows detect hard drive is failing

Swordphin123

Reputable
Nov 11, 2014
21
0
4,510
*Both Hard drives are 500 GB in size, one Western Digital which I had for many years and the newer one, Seagate

Alright, so yesterday night I decided to do a clean install of Windows 7 on my computer, erasing everything on my main C: (Western Digital) drive and backing up important informations on my other hard drive (Seagate, which is new that I bought a couple days back). After installing the OS again on my main C:/ drive, and making a 250 GB partition out of it, my computer was back up and running with a clean version of Windows 7. However, a message popped up claiming that I should backup my files since the drive was failing soon (didn't need to do this since it was a clean install of windows).

I looked for suggestions by Googling and used the Seagate Tools for Windows which claimed that both of my drives passed the test and nothing seemed to be wrong with it. Mind you, before the clean install of the OS this message never appeared, only after doing a real clean install of windows prompt this message (same type of OS as well, 64-bit, Professional).

I don't know what I should do at this point. I'm probably going to run the Western Digital diagnosis when I get home since it IS the WD drive that is failing so Seagate may be biased here. Do you guys think it is something I should be concerned about?

*EDIT: There's also a side effect that's been happening recently. Sometimes when I start my computer, it doesn't boot to Windows 7, instead says something like "Select Boot device and press a key" (though I haven't encountered this error yet during the clean install) and there are also occasional freezes (which is one of main reason why I wanted to clean install). There still freezes during the explorer from time to time on the clean install, but it isn't as bad (max 4 sec).
 
Solution
Run the WD diagnostic.

It's really hard to say if you should be concerned or not but probably not.

As said BACKUP YOUR FILES. I use Acronis True Image (and there's a free version for WD drives) which can make a compressed backup IMAGE of your entire Windows partition. So I recommend doing that and replace it periodically to stay up to date (backup Image on the Seagate drive).

Acronis for WD: http://support.wdc.com/product/downloaddetail.asp?swid=119

(works for Seagate as well provided you have at least one WD HDD in your system)

Other:
I have a 3TB HDD from Seagate and it kept telling me my drive was failing. I didn't believe it. I finally did a Low Level Format, then a Full NTFS format and the error went away and 1-year later...
Run the WD diagnostic.

It's really hard to say if you should be concerned or not but probably not.

As said BACKUP YOUR FILES. I use Acronis True Image (and there's a free version for WD drives) which can make a compressed backup IMAGE of your entire Windows partition. So I recommend doing that and replace it periodically to stay up to date (backup Image on the Seagate drive).

Acronis for WD: http://support.wdc.com/product/downloaddetail.asp?swid=119

(works for Seagate as well provided you have at least one WD HDD in your system)

Other:
I have a 3TB HDD from Seagate and it kept telling me my drive was failing. I didn't believe it. I finally did a Low Level Format, then a Full NTFS format and the error went away and 1-year later things are still fine.
 
Solution
Your system making you select a boot device could be because the primary boot device is having problems, or because your BIOS is getting "forgetful" of what drives you have attached. The former is consistent with a failing drive, and the latter could be because your BIOS battery is about done. If your system is more than 2-3 years old, you may need to replace the CMOS battery. Most likely it is a CR2032, but it could be a different size, so check it first. Depending on the brand and source, a new one shouldn't cost any more than $5; may be as little as $2.
 

ebm9000

Reputable
Jan 22, 2015
117
0
4,760
It displays that message for any failing drive on the system (the Windows error that is). The BIOS error confirms the drive is on its way out. Use a SMART data utility. If the UMA error count is high, its probably just the cable, but you never know...