Is the Xeon E3 1230 V3 any decent for gaming?

Woody1999

Admirable
Hiya all.

I haven't even built my proposed i3/Krait build yet (http://uk.pcpartpicker.com/user/Woody1999/saved/pxKMnQ) and I'm already planning upgrades for it. I'll probably get a new graphics card first, then a better PSU, and then some more RAM...and finally a new CPU.

I've noticed that all you hear when discussing gaming rigs is i5s and overclocking and all of that, but everyone overlooks the Xeons, retailing for a cheaper price with seemingly a helluva lot more performance. The Xeon E3-1230V3 is effectively, an i7 4770 with the integrated graphics taken out. It retains all the useful features like Hyperthreading, but sacrifices a bit of speed and the integrated graphics (unnecessary) for an i5 4690K price tag.

I had an i7 4770 for about a month, but a friend "broke" it by squeezing a little hard when he was squinting at the writing when I was installing a new motherboard. In that lucky month I had it, it was great. Super fast, good enough for all my gaming needs (had an HD 6990 as well till it set on fire in my case) and was generally great. If I can get effectively the same processor for £60 less, why not?

I plan on a bit of video editing, some streaming and maybe server hosting as well in the future, and of course I want to game on it as well. Would it hold out as well as an i7 4770 in games or is there secretly something different that makes it hopeless? Would a 4690K be a better option?

Woody
 

sirstinky

Distinguished
Aug 17, 2012
644
0
19,360
Ok so the Xeons are built the same way as the rest of Intel's chips, whether Sandy Bridge, Ivy Bridge, or Haswell E3/5-xxxv3. For your application, unless you are going to be doing A LOT of video editing and server-type stuff, the i7 will be just fine. Typically, the difference between Xeons and enthusiast processors is in their guts. A Xeon is built for reliability (24/7 operations, as in a server, or NAS), and able to handle very high I/O like in a server (DC, File, web, database, storage), basically like how many cars can go around a roundabout at once. More I/O=more cars. So, in effect, it's enterprise quality, which is why they are more expensive than consumer chips. They can also run what's called ECC, or buffered RAM, which is able to correct memory errors before they get passed onto the rest of the system. Consumer chips can't.

That said, you can use them for gaming, but they aren't ideal. They typically have lower clock rates as well and can't be overclocked (if that's important to you). They are also designed to run certain drivers better (like with workstation graphics cards), and don't have the iGPU (on-chip graphics), so you have to run a separate graphics card.

As far as the the "more performance" part, there really isn't as they are pretty much the same processors, just the Xeon is like a Bentley and the i7 is more like a Mercedes. Unless you REALLY want a Xeon, then you'll be better off with the i7 or even i5, since there's little difference between the two in games (and most other apps with the exception of multithreaded ones where the hyper threading is a definite advantage).
 

con635

Honorable
Oct 3, 2013
645
0
11,010
Its an i7 4770 with no igp, it will perform just like the i7 and cost less, any benchmark you see with the 4770 that's what it will do. Just check your mobo for compatibility, some boards dont like xeons.
 

Woody1999

Admirable


I'll be using the Z97S SLI Krait, would that be okay?

Woody
 

adavid

Reputable
Apr 1, 2015
77
0
4,640


unless you will be using the SLI feature, no point getting a z97 "overclocking ready" motherboard for a chip that doesn't overclock. a h97 board will be just fine for this kind of processor.
 

Woody1999

Admirable
The build is based around a black and white theme. Unfortunately, MSI doesn't make the Krait edition for any other chipsets in LGA1150. It's okay, I value the great features for the price, SLI and Crossfire capability, and beautiful looks.

Woody