Is it safe to install a 2.5" HDD in my desktop´s SSD bay?

fedohera

Reputable
May 12, 2015
3
0
4,510
Hello,

I'd like to know if it is safe to place my dead laptop´s disk in one of my dektop´s SSD bays, my main concern is about air flow. My case is a Corsair Carbide 200R which features 2 SSD bays. I never had a SSD before but my guessings are that unlike HDD they don´t need a lot of ventilation.

The drive i want to plug in my PC is a 2.5" Samsung HDD I extracted from my broken Notebook. I really want to recover my data so I first tried using an appropiate enclosure. By doing this i found that my PC´s Disk Manager recognizes my drive as Dynamic and invalid (not showing it in the explorer), tried to reactivate the disk but the manager failed since "that action is not allowed in an invalid disk". That´s why I want to try plugging it directly to my Motherboard hoping that is the enclosure the faulty one and not my drive.

Additional info:
My Dektop´s OS is Windows 7 Ultimate 64-bit edition
The OS installed in my 2.5" drive is Windows 7 Home Premium 64-bit edition. there are also few partitions on it, one containing the OS, one for my files and another one for the System Recovery partition installed by the manufacturer (HP).

Thank you in advance.
 
Solution
Yes you can. They say SSD candy ects but it is all 2.5 inch drives which doesn't matter if it is a SSD or a HDD. They all have the same mounting.

and laptop drives usually run cooler than normal drives so air flow shouldn't be an issue. Most laptops doesn't even have a fan cooling down the hard drive.

They all use the same Power and SATA Connector as well so you can just plug it straight into a SATA port and SATA power in your PC.

Though it sounds like you may have a failing/failed hard drive as well.
Yes you can. They say SSD candy ects but it is all 2.5 inch drives which doesn't matter if it is a SSD or a HDD. They all have the same mounting.

and laptop drives usually run cooler than normal drives so air flow shouldn't be an issue. Most laptops doesn't even have a fan cooling down the hard drive.

They all use the same Power and SATA Connector as well so you can just plug it straight into a SATA port and SATA power in your PC.

Though it sounds like you may have a failing/failed hard drive as well.
 
Solution

fedohera

Reputable
May 12, 2015
3
0
4,510


Thank you.

Edit:
Just connected the drive directly to the motherboard and... it's alive! I can acces my files again.
Anyone getting the "Dynamic Invalid" problem on a drive inside an enclosure, try this solution, it worked for me.