Fixed vs Removable USB Flash Drives.

koreanghost

Reputable
Feb 19, 2014
3
0
4,510
Hello Community!

I have a question and I have searched for quite some time now.

So my dilemma begins with my SanDisk Extreme USB 3.0 listing itself as "fixed" since the beginning. I know that SanDisk has made this drive to be "fixed" rather than "removable" for Win8 however with an uproar and disapproval from the community, has reverted back to shipping these as standard "fixed."

My question is: What's are the pros and cons of having a fixed vs removable USB drive?

Is it the way that some of the data is cached on a fixed drive? I'm asking because I have some sensitive files I would like to store away on the USB drive, however I am conflicted if I have to consistently ensure that I have no data being read/write onto the drive and turning off my computer every single time I would like to pull out my USB. Am I at a larger risk of losing data vs removable due to writing caching on device? Or should I just make sure that all data is written and move on with my life? Also being "fixed" would this have the same I guess "hot swap" -ability as some HDD's and SSD's are able to do?

Thank you.
 
Solution


Traditionally, Windows (and maybe other OS) will only let you install over a fixed drive. The logic being, the OS needs to be there at ALL TIMES, and it would be very unhappy if you decide to unplug it in the middle of things. But I guess these days high capacity flash drives are everywhere and it's very convenient to boot from removables, am guessing why Win8 is making an exception.

According to Windows, if you intend to have your removables, they are mostly referring to USB-attached, be able to be removed without going through the standard shutdown process, to DISABLE the drive's cache.

I personally always go through the regular shutdown...


Traditionally, Windows (and maybe other OS) will only let you install over a fixed drive. The logic being, the OS needs to be there at ALL TIMES, and it would be very unhappy if you decide to unplug it in the middle of things. But I guess these days high capacity flash drives are everywhere and it's very convenient to boot from removables, am guessing why Win8 is making an exception.

According to Windows, if you intend to have your removables, they are mostly referring to USB-attached, be able to be removed without going through the standard shutdown process, to DISABLE the drive's cache.

I personally always go through the regular shutdown process, a few extra seconds doesn't bother me.
 
Solution

TRENDING THREADS