JackNaylorPE :
Both the NAS and the network printer were on power strips... they are both dead. None of the machines on UPS were damaged.
Protection in a UPS is often inferior to what is in a power strip. Manufacturer specifications and numbers from InvalidError demonstrate same.
Knowledge only from observation is classic junk science. Always include fundamental and proven knowledge - the science. A surge (ie lightning strike far down the street) is a surge incoming to every appliance. Is every appliance damaged? Of course not. An outgoing path to earth must also exist to have damage. A surge hunts for and finds the appliances that make a best connection to earth. Those damaged appliances then act as surge protectors for all other appliances. That science explains why some appliances are damages; others are not.
That hunt blows through anything that might stop it - including UPS or power strip protectors. Meanwhile, a UPS typically leaves the appliance directly connected to AC mains when not in battery backup mode. Where is the protection? Only speculation from observation (without first learning how surges do damage) made that claim.
Some mistakenly claim a UPS battery will absorb a surge. Again, a conclusion without first learning fundamental concepts. To a surge, that battery is simply an electrical conductor (superposition). It gives a surge even more destructive paths into attached electronics. Where is the protection? Just another reason why UPS spec numbers do not claim superior protection.
Protection at an appliance is already done better inside the appliance. Effective protection means a surge must not enter the building - does not go hunting for earth destrutively via appliances. Protection is always defined by one simple question: Where do hundreds of thousands of joules harmlessly dissipate? Outside the building and away from appliances.
Damage from power cycling is averted by another function. A safety lockout circuit powers off the PSU. This lockout is released by removing the power cord from AC mains. Some computers do not have this hardware safety feature. And some power supplies, sold on more watts, may also be more succeptible. So a UPS, outputting 'dirty' power, would have averted this damage. Power cycling does not create surges. Different anomaly.