Which portable hard drive shall I buy ?

Digesh Patel

Reputable
Jun 14, 2015
3
0
4,510
Hello all. I am looking to buy a 2 TB portable hard drive and I have narrowed down my choice to 3 options.

1. WD My Passport Ultra - http://www.amazon.com/Passport-Ultra-Portable-External-WDBBKD0020BBK-NESN/dp/B00W8XXYSM/ref=dp_ob_title_ce

2. Toshiba Canveo Connect II - http://www.amazon.com/Toshiba-Connect-Portable-Storage-HDTC820XK3C1/dp/B00R4O9HCM

3. Seagate Backup Plus Slim - http://www.amazon.com/Seagate-Backup-Portable-External-STDR2000100/dp/B00FRHTSK4

I would be very thankful if someone could guide me further in buying one of these. Could anyone compare the performance of these drives ? Design and portability doesn't matter much to me. I would like to have a drive which is fast and has software which could meet my primary purpose of backing up full system image of my windows system. What I have read so far is that seagate drives have higher failure rates and WD's software has some bugs. Both WD and Seagate does not offer full system image backups. I am also aware that we could easily backup system image using windows utilities in windows 7 and 8. So full system image backup is not much of an issue but if there is one, I would go for it; as in case of the toshiba drive. But I haven't heard much of toshiba drives and don't know how it would perform compared to seagate or WD. If toshiba is reliable and performs like the other two, I would go for it since it has additional software features and also hardware level encryption.

So I would request someone to please help me with this and letting me know the performance of these drives. Thank You.
 
Solution
WD is the better Brand. I would rather have software bugs (not like anyone really uses the software anyways)

Go for Option #1

It also features usb 3.0 (blazing fast transfer speeds, would work if your pc has usb 3.0 slots which are blue in color), drive encryption if you decide in the future you want to encrypt your data or prevent others from accessing it.

I wouldn't trust toshiba.

WD external drives don't fail as much as those other brands, has a 3 year warranty and they offer better customer support in my opinion.

Reyaz123

Admirable
WD is the better Brand. I would rather have software bugs (not like anyone really uses the software anyways)

Go for Option #1

It also features usb 3.0 (blazing fast transfer speeds, would work if your pc has usb 3.0 slots which are blue in color), drive encryption if you decide in the future you want to encrypt your data or prevent others from accessing it.

I wouldn't trust toshiba.

WD external drives don't fail as much as those other brands, has a 3 year warranty and they offer better customer support in my opinion.
 
Solution

Digesh Patel

Reputable
Jun 14, 2015
3
0
4,510


Thanks for your prompt response. I think I would go with WD. The only thing that toshiba appealed me was it's software and it's cloud backup options. But I don't know how it would perform compared to WD.
 

Reyaz123

Admirable
If you are interested in using cloud, upload important files to something like "Google Drive (15GB offered free)" or "Dropbox" (2GB of space only for free). These are alternatives if that is what you are asking about.

The only reason I believe the toshiba drive you listed there could be better than the WD drive, is if you own a mac computer. It doesn't need reformatting to be able to switch from windows to mac.
 

Digesh Patel

Reputable
Jun 14, 2015
3
0
4,510

Correct. My final decision is WD. It also offers hardware level encryption and regarding backup, windows 8 too offers full system image backups. So thank you once again.
 

Reyaz123

Admirable


No problem, glad I could help

-Reyaz