antec vp700p vs thermaltake smart se 730w

rapidflyhigh · Jun 20, 2015

who's the best between these two power supplies
antec vp700p http://www.antec.com/pdf/flyers/VP700P_Flyer_EN_20140320.pdf
or
thermaltake smart se 730w http://www.thermaltake.com/products-model.aspx?id=C_00001966
(both psu are at the same price)

koffeeshop77 · Jun 20, 2015

the antec is beter then thermal tec hands down

galeener · Jun 20, 2015

The only thermal take I would buy would be the toughpower or toughpower grand series

ko888 · Jun 20, 2015

The capacitor quality in both models is about the same. The Antec VP700P uses all CapXon capacitors and the Thermaltake Smart SE 730W uses a mix of AiSHi and CapXon capacitors.

They are budget PSUs so don't expect any great quality from them.

Zerk2012 · Jun 20, 2015

Neither one is high enough quality for me to consider buying the Antec is better but only a 2 year warranty tells you of the parts used to make it.

rapidflyhigh · Jun 20, 2015

Zerk2012 :

what about the cooler master g750m http://www.coolermaster.com/powersupply/modular-gm-series/g750m/.

ko888 · Jun 20, 2015

The latest published return rates due to failure show that the Cooler Master GM Series have some of the highest return rates.

SherbetAddict · Jun 20, 2015

ko888 :

What about the Silverstone Strider Essential?

ko888 · Jun 20, 2015

SherbetAddict :

If it's the SilverStone Strider Essential Gold 700W then sure. That model uses better quality components and uses a more modern circuit design.

If it's the SilverStone Strider Essential Bronze 700W ST70F-ESB it's no better than the previous models you were looking at. This model is based on an older group regulated circuit design and is built with cheap capacitors.

danisnotonfire · Jun 21, 2015

rapidflyhigh :

They're actually good PSUs. Internal component quality could be better but according to TPU the vreg and ripple suppression on those are fantastic.

ko888 · Jun 21, 2015

danisnotonfire :

The 550W model that TPU reviewed uses a Japanese Panasonic primary capacitor and a mix of CapXon and JunFu capacitors on the secondary.

The 750W model uses two JunFu capacitors on the primary and a mix of CapXon and JunFu capacitors on the secondary.

That's definitely not better, quality-wise.

rapidflyhigh · Jun 21, 2015

ko888 :

danisnotonfire :

The 550W model that TPU reviewed uses a Japanese Panasonic primary capacitor and a mix of CapXon and JunFu capacitors on the secondary.

The 750W model uses two JunFu capacitors on the primary and a mix of CapXon and JunFu capacitors on the secondary.

That's definitely not better, quality-wise.

okay thank you last question is cooler master 700w thunder better than the two first psu in the title.
http://www.coolermaster.com/powersupply/thunder/thunder-700w/

Zerk2012 · Jun 21, 2015

rapidflyhigh :

ko888 :

okay thank you last question is cooler master 700w thunder better than the two first psu in the title.
http://www.coolermaster.com/powersupply/thunder/thunder-700w/

This would be a lot quicker if you list the parts your using, where your going to buy from, and what you can spend.

rapidflyhigh · Jun 21, 2015

Zerk2012 :

rapidflyhigh :

This would be a lot quicker if you list the parts your using, where your going to buy from, and what you can spend.

i live in algeria my system will be like 8350 + r9 290x (2*4gb) 970a ds3p
her's the sites from what i can buy
http://geekzonedz.com/boutique/index.php/alimentation-pc.html
http://www.lahlou-industry.com/composants-pc/alimentation?zenid=d51e9b54c8fcfb1785de6ddd8e6bdcd5
http://www.twins-multimedia.com/?rub=liste_produit&ID=1&SID=54&SSID=116
http://www.weltinfodz.com/listeproduits.php?type=Alimentation%20PC
i can spend max 14000~15000da on a psu
(i will never ever overclock anything)

danisnotonfire · Jun 21, 2015

ko888 :

danisnotonfire :

The 550W model that TPU reviewed uses a Japanese Panasonic primary capacitor and a mix of CapXon and JunFu capacitors on the secondary.

The 750W model uses two JunFu capacitors on the primary and a mix of CapXon and JunFu capacitors on the secondary.

That's definitely not better, quality-wise.

Did you even read what I said before replying? It shows it above if you need it again. I said that internal components like capacitors could be better. Vreg and ripple were what I was praising the GM for.

http://www.techpowerup.com/reviews/CoolerMaster/G550M/

ko888 · Jun 21, 2015

danisnotonfire :

And I said, above, that the latest published return rates due to failure show that the Cooler Master GM series have the highest rates.

Capacitor quality determines reliability. Voltage regulation and ripple and noise levels won't matter if the PSU has failed.

What reviews fail to show is anything about reliability because it is a sampling of only one unit.

Zerk2012 · Jun 21, 2015

ko888 :

The reviews can also be bad because they can hand pick a good one out of the lot the same as getting the +certification.
Most people have no clue about power supplies it's good to see somebody that actually looks at what their made of.

Search

antec vp700p vs thermaltake smart se 730w

rapidflyhigh

Honorable

koffeeshop77

Reputable

galeener

Distinguished

ko888

Titan

Zerk2012

Titan

rapidflyhigh

Honorable

ko888

Titan

SherbetAddict

Reputable

ko888

Titan

danisnotonfire

Reputable

ko888

Titan

rapidflyhigh

Honorable

Zerk2012

Titan

rapidflyhigh

Honorable

danisnotonfire

Reputable

ko888

Titan

Zerk2012

Titan

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts

Moderators online

Share this page