You'll need a new heatsink.
The athlon II came with a decent heatsink for its 65w it used but the PhenomII 955 uses almost twice as much power (125w) and will just overheat
Heres the 65w heatsink. Notice its just a block of finned metal witha fan on it. 65w isnt a lot of heat to dissapate.
and here's the 125w Heatsink. Notice its a much larger block with heatpipes. 125w is quite a bit.
I've removed the Best Answer you gave IntelTurtleFan as I do not want others thinking that this would work when it might even damage their system. You can assign it to someone who recommends you a good heatsink to use with your new cpu.
Can you tel us what size case you have? How tall a heatsink you can fit?