Motherboard / CPU suggestions for "media center" and backup storage PC?

Magnus Eriksson

Distinguished
May 16, 2013
4
0
18,510
I would like to upgrade my existing combined multimedia and storage PC (it is a few years old and uses a low power AMD E-350 CPU) since I am disappointed with the video streaming performance under Windows 8 / 8.1 / 10.

The box is located in a utility room next to my living room and uses my TV as screen (DVI cable) and a wireless Logitech keyboard (receiver on a USB extension cable in the living room).

I already own a good chassis (full size from fractal design) and a total of 7 disks (6 "green" mechanical SATA disks and a fairly new SSD as boot drive), and a good PSU (platinum 400 W).

I am NOT interested to do any gaming on the PC but would like video from all providers (YouTube, Netflix etc) to run "smooth as butter" in 1080p resolution (we have high bandwidth fiber connection with low latency so this is not a problem on some Gaming PCs we already own).

As a file server it does not need to perform "ultra fast" - we mainly use it for storing backups of all other PCs in the house and as a "media library" for saved video, music and extensive photo collections - it can be assumed that no heavy disk access needs to be performed at the same time as streaming video (even though it would be nice if it could serve some files without video streaming become "choppy").

The machine is backed up to cloud storage for disaster recovery.

Since the box is intended to be running 24x7 I am looking for using as low power components as is possible without compromising on the goal of very good video streaming performance. I am not overly budget conscious but nobody wants to "throw money away needlessly" so good value for money suggestions are appreciated!
 
My first question is a licensing issue - did you build the previous machine and install a retail / OEM version of the OS, or did you buy it prebuilt? The licenses from prebuilt machines that came with the OS are not transferrable.

From what I have read, if the machine is going to be up 24x7 you need a different OS anyway - a server OS. Certainly, my frequently-off windows 7 machine works better than my wife's, which might get shut down once a month. Microsoft put out Windows Home Server specifically for people running, well, home servers. So my unasked-for advice is to look into a home server OS while you are choosing the components that you did ask about.
 

Magnus Eriksson

Distinguished
May 16, 2013
4
0
18,510


Thanks for the suggestion!

I have access to a Windows 8 license that is transferable to other machines and uppgradable to Windows 10 (I have actually already done the upgrade and came to the conclusion that the old motherboard / CPU does not cut it when it comes to video streaming using this OS).

My primary focus with this build is in fact video streaming with low energy consumption and the secondary one is file storage.

I have actually been running a server OS (Linux) on the machine before but due to lack of expertise (and time to further look into it) all the time had different issues with Samba not working as smooth for the family as I would like it too (we had different problems with the mounted disks having to be re-mounted, the server sometimes not showing up under "Network" until after a long time, no support for "home group" etc) so I thought I should try running Windows on the box instead - I was also curios to test Windows 10 and had a spare Windows 8 license.

With Windows (both 8.1 and 10) the box do in fact , as expected,work flawlessly from the disk sharing perspective but unfortunately it does not work well with my old hardware for streaming (as I mentioned it lags like crazy when playing back video from Internet and I have already tried quite a few things to reduce it without being able to solve it) so if I continue down this road it seems like I will need to upgrade the CPU / motherboard as well...

Preferably I would not like to buy a new OS as well as this adds to the cost further (as I have no other use for the Windows 8 license) but I will consider your advice.