Build Critique - Mini Photo Workstation (z170 vs x99)

Eggz

Distinguished
The build is for a wedding venue with in-house photography. They use Lightroom and Photoshop. The business has a huge photo library. Lightroom is a database application that needs fast access to the database file, especially for large libraries. That's why there's the Intel 750. It also needs storage for original files, and that's where the money maker is for them, so that's why there's a 3 TB RAID 1 (drive failure protection). They also backup on site so as not to exclusively rely on the RAID.

Lightroom and Photoshop need as much CPU and RAM as possible, and I originally was going to only consider the 5820k, but the new Skylake 6700k does pretty good. There's no difference in PCIe lanes (functionally) because they are going to only use 20 max on the x99 (or 12 if the z170 switches that way), since it will be a GPU with a nVME SSD on the M.2.

They also want a show piece customized with their logo and stuff, which is why the fancy case; otherwise, it might just drive the cost too high. Nonetheless, they are shooting for no more than $2,500.

The main point of choice would be the motherboard if z170 turns out to be the right way to go. They want USB 3.1 (preferably Type-C, since that seems to be pushed for the new standard), WiFi, and M.2 supporting PCIe 3.0 x 4. The trick with the (yet to be released) mITX board with z170 is that the M.2 connectivity is spotty. The AsRock board I picked out has the M.2 slot in the back, making the Hyper Kit needed to connect the Intel 750 SSD require case modification. The Hyper Kit will stick out the back and not allow the motherboard to fit unless I cut out a space. If there are easier options, I am open to whatever.

What are people's thoughts on saving money vs performance on the two builds below?

z170 - http://pcpartpicker.com/p/3vN6zy (~$2,380)

x99 - http://pcpartpicker.com/p/8Zrvxr (~$2,450)

 
I'm using lightroom on an i5-3570k, with a gtx970 and the edits are instant, the catalogue files are on an SSD, the images are on spinning disks.

My point behind this is that the x platforms may not be needed.

You may want to consider storage spaces vs raid, so that you can grow the amount of storage more easily and more easily have a hot spare disk.
 

Eggz

Distinguished
It's definitely not needed now, but they made it clear that they want the machine to be relevant for at least 5 years. Now I know "relevant" isn't top-of-the-line, but with DX 12 and Windows 10, the thought about X99 was better core utilization down the line. Plus, the cost difference was only about $70.
 

Eggz

Distinguished
I think I'm going to leave it in RAID 1 rather than use spaces, since I know the RAID will be OS agnostic (though perhaps not motherboard). Spaces might be too, but I haven't used it enough to give to someone for a build, and I know the RAID 1 will work no problem. As for backup, I think they have a system where they'll have everything copied over after each major wedding, and then they'll offload the RAID to archives either every year or as it gets full. No too worried about the storage integrity of the setup.

The main concern is price. The storage costs so much, but they need the performance as well. And they want the fancy case. Too bad Z170 isn't looking to be much cheaper than X99 :-/
 
why pro windows? are they on a domain? understand what pro offers you, it's not a lot for normal people, and you can always do an anytime upgrade if they really need it.

There are cheaper ways of getting a 400GB SSD, that will be very nearly as fast, probably unnoticeably slower. I really don't think you'll gain from 32GB of ram, 16 should be plenty, and again if it's not it's an easy cheap upgrade in 2-3 years time.

that could shave off an easy $200, you could also get a smaller or cheaper PSU, you can get very good PSU's for about 1/2 that price. I'd also suggest that a big air cooler will be quieter, just as cool, cheaper, and not require refilling/replacing in 2-3 years, just blowing out perhaps. That's another $100. Why a fatality board? why not a server board? (if they are out yet, probably not), but a tough series might be more appropriate, but still overkill. My server at home is on for 14 hrs a day, been running for 5 years, and is a basic amd matx board, another $50 perhaps? You could easily get that below $2200 with no real sacrifice maybe lower

edited to bring 2000 up to 2200.
 

Eggz

Distinguished
Yeah, I think a lot of the cost derives from that case. They won't budge. It's mITX. For X99, there's exactly one option, and most of the Z170 options are still coming out. Even the one I picked isn't yet out. Maybe I'll just tell them to up the budget to avoid dealing with upgrades later on, especially since a whole business will rely on it.