Can't seem to get into any games. Need some recommendations!

Have this high end system and I'm unable to get hooked on any recent titles for pc. I've played quite a lot of others including new titles. just looking for some opinions.

All-Time Favs (PC And Console)

Final Fantasy 9
Heroes Of Newerth
Grand Theft Auto (Series)
Dead Island
Forza Motorsport (Series)
Starcraft 1
Quake III
Fallout 3
World Of Warcraft (Vanilla Only)
BioShock Infinite
Borderlands 2
Unreal Tournament 2004
Pokemon Red & Blue
Paper Mario
Super Mario 64
Sonic Adventure
Soul Calibur 1
Super Mario Bros.