Which Motherboard is Better for My Build?

Edit_Hax

Reputable
Feb 10, 2015
52
0
4,630
Hey all,
I was planning on doing a specific build that I had had in mind for a while, but I recently saw a motherboard that was cheaper than my original, and fit a red/black color scheme that I want to go with. I will ALWAYS prioritize quality and features over looks, because I am budget building, but the MSI motherboard looked really nice.

My PCPARTPICKER List: http://pcpartpicker.com/p/MPqThM

My Original Choice Motherboard:http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813132510&nm_mc=AFC-C8Junction&cm_mmc=AFC-C8Junction-Skimlinks-_-na-_-na-_-na&AID=12087162&PID=3987229&SID=skim92X590208X629d94e5314e2888feb35d3c09dcef5c&utm_medium=affiliates&utm_source=afc-Skimlinks

My New Better-Looking Motherboard Choice: http://www.amazon.com/MSI-DDR3-Motherboards-Z97-G45-GAMING/dp/B00K23BYCI/ref=sr_1_8?s=pc&ie=UTF8&qid=1440219889&sr=1-8&keywords=msi+motherboard+gaming+7

Which one is better/better for the money?
 
Solution
There's not a whole lot of difference there. The biggest difference would probably be in the power phases for the cpu. Not a whole lot of info on the g45 gaming, no real reviews or anything specific to that board. As far as being military class components, it's more or less a marketing gimmick. I'm not entirely sure since I don't work in the industry but some people who do say the particular military test specs they use are essentially a free testing method where iso and others cost money. That the standards for the mil-std-810g they're tested to aren't any more rigorous than typical testing motherboards go through. The gold plated socket bit on the gigabyte is a bit of a marketing ploy as well, I'm sure technically it may make a slight...
I'm not sure the msi has more features. The only place it appears to have more features is in pcie 3.0 slots. It has 3 pcie 3.0 x16 where the asus has 2 pcie 3.0 x16 and 1 pcie 2.0 x16 slots. Either way, it becomes a bit pointless. The z97 chipset only has 16 pcie lanes, so regardless which board they will both support the same things. Either a single amd/nvidia card, 2 way crossfire/2 way sli or 3 way crossfire (x8/x4/x4). Neither will support 3 way sli since they're limited to x8/x8 and sli won't run in x4.

If comparing the ports, the msi appears to have 4 usb3 and 2 usb 1.1 while the asus only has 4 usb 3.0 - but if you continue looking at the specs, the asus z97-a also has 6 usb ports to the rear, the other 2 being usb 3.1 which the msi doesn't have. The asus has more modern tech in this case. They also both run the typical configuration of ports where both have 6 sata headers but only 4 are operable if using m.2 or sata express. The msi doesn't seem to list sata express as an option, just m.2 but it might just be a detail omission.

Personally I'd opt for this board which has a promo going right now marking it down from $145 to $125 after $20 mail in rebate. Even without the rebate it's a killer deal. The gigabyte gaming 7 is a better board than either of those in my opinion. It does lack usb 3.1 but has more sata headers (8), 7.1ch audio and if overclocking has the benefit of higher power phases. The asus board uses 4 digital power phases with doubler, the gd45 has 8 phases I believe and likely 4 with a doubler though not sure if they're analog/hybrids like most of the msi lineup or digital like the gd65. The gigabyte gaming 7 doesn't rely on doublers and features 8 true digital phases which results in more stable power delivery for overclocking.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128708&cm_re=z97x_gaming_7-_-13-128-708-_-Product

If it's strictly between the two boards mentioned in the original post I'd opt for the asus. Even with such similar features, for overall quality I'd personally go for asus/gigabyte over asrock/msi. Unless you go straight to the bottom of the barrel cheapest possible board it's hard to go wrong with most of the mid to upper end z series boards. By then it's mostly nitpicking so if it seems that way it's because it is.
 

Edit_Hax

Reputable
Feb 10, 2015
52
0
4,630


Hmmm. I still think the MSI one looks way cooler, especially to go with an MSI Frozer V GTX 970, but I'm just nitpicking about colors. The gigabyte seems to have M.2 support, which I won't be using, because my SSD only supports 6gb/s (correct me if I'm wrong). The only thing that may be different is the construction, but MSI says it's "military class 4 components" and the Gigabyte supports "10k durable black-caps." Is there really that big a difference? The Gigabyte seems to have better audio and whatnot, and also has a gold-plated CPU socket, but does any of that make a major difference?
 
There's not a whole lot of difference there. The biggest difference would probably be in the power phases for the cpu. Not a whole lot of info on the g45 gaming, no real reviews or anything specific to that board. As far as being military class components, it's more or less a marketing gimmick. I'm not entirely sure since I don't work in the industry but some people who do say the particular military test specs they use are essentially a free testing method where iso and others cost money. That the standards for the mil-std-810g they're tested to aren't any more rigorous than typical testing motherboards go through. The gold plated socket bit on the gigabyte is a bit of a marketing ploy as well, I'm sure technically it may make a slight difference but honestly plenty of plain old sockets from back in the day functioned just fine.

I can't seem to get a clear cut list of 'what's included' with both those boards but it appears the msi comes with 2 sata cables (1 straight, 1 90* angled) and it looks like the gigabyte comes with 4, (2 straight, 2 90* angled). Both include an sli bridge. My gigabyte boards came with 4 sata cables but they were a different model so I can't really say for sure. The pic of what comes in the box on newegg is a bit of a bad angle to tell for sure.

None of those things likely make a huge difference, if the color is important to you then get whichever one you like the color of the best. Both are decent boards and should work fine. If one was complete junk and the other was premium it would be much easier to say 'get this one' but that's not the case.
 
Solution

Edit_Hax

Reputable
Feb 10, 2015
52
0
4,630


Thanks for the response. I've decided to go with the MSI one, as my GPU is also going to be MSI, and both of them will have a red/black color scheme as well as a dragon painted on it. As we all know, dragons are badass, and therefore the win goes to the MSI board.