Seagate external making weird sounds/acting strange

pseudorian

Reputable
Sep 7, 2015
2
0
4,510
I've had this Seagate 2TB GoFlex 2TB for a few years now and am just now starting to have some problems with it.

I'd left my computer running (nothing actively running from the external HD) for about 6 hours while I was away. Before leaving, there were no problems. When I returned, the drive had a lot of trouble accessing data. I decided to restart my computer, but it refused to bring me to the Windows login page until I tried unplugging my external HD (it started making some strange noise, so I thought it was worth a shot). Once I logged in, I plugged the HD back in and it kept continuously making a noise as if it was repeatedly trying to access something on the drive, then it would vibrate hard and, once again, start repeating the noise in a loop. I tried accessing the HD and it would run extremely slowly.

I decided to try it on my laptop and, unfortunately, it had the same problem. Plugged it back into my desktop and it began disconnecting occasionally without apparent reason. At this point, I tried to be patient and try copying some data to see if a backup would be easy. It struggled at first, but then the noise would stop and the files would copy at full speed. As soon as copying was complete, the noise would return. So I'm thinking it's doing something strange while idling (even partially; playing a video causing it to make the noise sporadically and only load about 5 seconds of video at a time).

Any idea what the problem might be?

I'm running it through USB 3.0, though I tried the 2.0 and no difference. Running Windows 7 Ultimate on the desktop and Windows 8 Basic on laptop.

P.S. Just remembered that my motherboard's monitoring software (AI Suite II) has been giving my voltage shortage notices the last several days, but I've been disregarding it as it seems many people report this as being inaccurate. I would suggest that maybe the drive isn't getting enough power (if that would make sense; I don't have a lot of technical knowledge on this subject), but, like I said, the drive runs at full speed when occupied with copying files.
 

Goujiin

Reputable
Mar 30, 2015
7
0
4,510
Hard drives in any shape and form are far from perfect. Unfortunately, your external drive is likely dying. Not much can be done with it without sending it in for repairs which could cost as much or more than the unit to be told it died.

I had bought a brand new hard drive yesterday and it would rapidly spin and click lots but would never read. it was dead on arrival. these happen, unfortunately.

I would suggest transferring whatever files you can onto a flash drive and getting a new one. chances are, the newer one will even last longer. If you have the funds to, get a Solid State drive. there will be no clicking, compact for storage and is faster since it has no moving parts.

Sorry for your loss.
 

pseudorian

Reputable
Sep 7, 2015
2
0
4,510
Well, I started it up this morning and it seems to be working fine now. Maybe just a bit overworked? From idling? heh no idea.

But I will probably take your advice and pick up a new one sometime soon. The timing couldn't be much worse as I'm in between a big move and won't be starting my new job for a couple more weeks. But you are probably correct anyway.