HGST drives seem to have the lowest failure rates. But WD, HGST and Toshiba are all good drives in my book. And yes, it seems like everytime I try a Seagate drive, it fails way too early on me. So I no longer buy Seagate.
Once you are back up and running, look into buying a copy of NovaSTOR backup. Its often on sale for $29.99. And get yourself a hard drive just for backups. $100 investment, and a whole lot of peace of mind. And if you would like to know which hard drive I bought, I can post the link for you whenever you want it.
I just want to show you a chart that a backup company named BackBlaze posted early this year. They have over 40,000 hard drives running as part of their operation. And this chart shows the failure rates of various sized drives by manufacturer. My experiences over the years matches this chart.