SSD RAID 0's Identicalilty Requirement

the_hooligan

Distinguished
Nov 11, 2006
5
0
18,510
Hello all, I have a question about the relationship between these newfangled M.2 slots and PCIe: is RAID 0's "identicality" requirement met if you use a 2.5" form factor M.2 + Hyper Kit SSD (e.g. SSDPE2MW400G4R5) and a normal PCIe form factor SSD (e.g. SSDPEDMW400G4R5)? Normally, RAID requires "identical" drives, and even though these drives are the same brand, same size, and use the same bus (PCIe), I'm curious if their different interfaces would preclude such an implementation.

For example, consider the new Asus Z170-Deluxe board, which has only one onboard M.2 slot, but is packaged with a PCIe --> M.2 adapter. It also advertises various configurations of RAID 0 support (see, e.g., the link above). Theoretically, to get RAID to work, you could start by plugging the 2.5" drive above into the M.2 slot using the included Hyper Kit adapter. But, for the second drive, would you really have to do this:

PCIe Slot --> PCIe/M.2 Adapater (included) --> (another) Hyper Kit --> MiniSAS cable --> 2.5" M.2 Drive?

Or could you just buy a native PCIe drive and plug it straight into that PCIe slot?

Hope this question makes sense. I understand that SSD RAID may not be practical, but I've enjoyed watching these technologies progress and I'm mostly just curious about the specifics. All input is welcome!
 

the_hooligan

Distinguished
Nov 11, 2006
5
0
18,510


Hi popatim! Wouldn't an M.2 slot (that uses PCIe 3.0 lanes) and a PCIe 3.0 slot use the same controller? Or are the M.2 slots offloaded to a different controller?
 

the_hooligan

Distinguished
Nov 11, 2006
5
0
18,510
Just to follow-up, I stumbled on this recent article from The SSD Review purporting to have created a RAID array from three NVMe 750 Series drives, two of which were M.2 form factor and one of which was PCIe form factor. The system was built using the new ASRock Z170 Extreme7+ board. In case anyone reading this was curious, it looks like it is possible to mix form factors as long as the interface ultimately uses PCIe 3.0 lanes (i.e. no PCIe 2.0 M.2 slots):

http://www.thessdreview.com/our-reviews/intel-750-u-2aic-ssd-raid0-x3-report-5gbs-750k-iops/

(Assuming, of course, that the BIOS supports such an implementation.)