Welcome to TH community, rossdal!
Sorry to hear about your issues with the WD Black, however, @drtweak is right! You might be encountering issues with the Windows XP installation, rather than the HDD. I'd recommend you to create a bootable USB flash drive with your Windows OS version and try booting from it instead. However, you might want to find another computer to create that bootable USB.
You'd also need a 64-bit version of Windows XP or the WD Align tool in order to be able to install the OS on the WD Black successfully. The drive is Advanced Format, which is not supported by the 32-bit Windows XP version.
Here's a link to the WD Align utility:
http://products.wdc.com/support/kb.ashx?id=eA1dFV
If the issue persists, I'd...