Would you try another video card? Or is the motherboard flawed?

Fulano5321

Reputable
Aug 10, 2015
70
1
4,640
I've got an old ASUS M4A785TD-M EVO 4 years ago that has always given occasional TDR errors. That's when windows decides the driver isn't responding like it should and resets the driver.

It'll usually start with brief screen flashes until either the display gets distorted with colorful noise or the driver resets and things go normal for a while.

The troubleshooting:
-I started with a GeForce 210 card, then upgraded to a 9800 GT. Still got the errors.
-I reinstalled windows a dozen times but both cards would get TDR errors several times a day (That's when Windows decides the video driver has crashed and restarts it).
-Over the years driver updates did make a huge difference in reducing the number of errors.
-I've checked voltages, they were all good.
-Also bought a new CPU, RAM and Hard drive, but didn't change anything.

Finally, I replaced the motherboard with an Intel board and am still using the 9800 GT. The errors have gone away so I suspect the error was related to the ASUS motherboard and possibly with NVIDIA cards.

The ASUS board is currently working with old hardware and it's integrated chip.

It's specs currently (made with old parts after I got the Intel board)
Windows 7 64 bit.
AMD Athlon II X2 270 Regor
Some generic 450 watt PSU
Mushkin Enhanced Silverline 2 x 4GB 1600
120 GB SSD


I'd like to get another video card (like a 730) for the ASUS board but I'm worried the TDR errors will come back.

So, would you try a different video card? Possibly an AMD card? Or do you think the motherboard has a flaw?
 

Fulano5321

Reputable
Aug 10, 2015
70
1
4,640

Thanks for the reply!
Had to do some digging to find any specs, they're old parts it's using now. :) I updated the post with the specs.

The PSU is currently generic. I'd like to get a low power card like a GT 730 at Newegg's Black Friday sale.

The PSU I was using before I got the Intel board was a Rosewill RP550V2-D-SL 550W. It's running beautifully now with the Intel board, so I don't think it was the issue, plus I did check it with a mlti-meter and everything checked out.

Also I forgot to mention I got a new CPU and RAM and the issue remained.
 

I would guess the generic PSU is the issue, they can cause all sorts of problems. Why did you switch out your Rosewill?
 

Fulano5321

Reputable
Aug 10, 2015
70
1
4,640

[strike]It's a long post... easy to miss the details. Sorry about that.[/strike] Seems I accidentally deleted the paragraph that explained that... Sorry!

I was using the Rosewill PSU when I had the issue. I got a new motherboard and am using it for my main computer.

I used the ASUS motherboard and old parts to build a computer to use at work. I'd like to get a video card for it but am concerned the TDR errors will happen again.
 

So the work PC is the one that had the TDR errors and you want to put a GPU in that? Sorry if I've misunderstood.
I'd say go for it and if the errors start again, then you can work out what is causing the issue when it comes to it, I'd say it was a power delivery or driver corruption issue.
 

Fulano5321

Reputable
Aug 10, 2015
70
1
4,640


Yes, sorry for my confusion. :)

So that is another factor, that the 730 having no extra power connections might not have an issue...

 

If the card doesn't have any 6 or 8 pin connectors, it will use less power so yes, there is less chance of power issues.