Which CPU heatsink/fan should I get?

G

Guest

Guest
I am torn between 2 fans:

1. The Zalman CNPS 8900 quiet
2. The Noctua NH-L12

In tests, the Noctua out-performs the Zalman.

The issue is size. The Noctua is quite tall so I would have to sacrifice the top of the two fans. Is it still better without this fan or does the Zalman push ahead?

I have an Alienware X51 case if you were curious.

Any help is appreciated.

Thanks.
 
G

Guest

Guest
Dimensions for the Zalman 120mm X 120mm X 60mm (Zalman site)
Cryorig 140mm X 144,5mm (heatsink sticks out a bit) X 74mm

Also I can't find anyone who has put the cryorig in the X51 so...