Immediate System Shutdown on Power, alternate PSU and MB already tried

ggtriela

Reputable
Nov 3, 2015
5
0
4,510
i7 4770K, stock heatsink
Asus Sabertooth Z87
Coolermaster V1000
2 x 8GB G.Skill DDR3
EVGA GTX770

Computer was running fine for about 3.5 years, then when updating some Windows (10) setting, I did a Windows-based reboot. Shutdown was fine, but on startup, I got 1 long, 3 short beep code.

Multiple reboots, same beep code.

Went through the forum sticky, now down to just cpu, mobo, 1 stick ram (alternating), psu. Checked for shorts. Now no more beep codes, but immediate shutdown a fraction of a second after power, no matter what. After a while, I discover that removing the CPU cable (from the psu to mobo) and powering will make the computer stay on with no shutdown.

Looked through forums, asked some Microcenter guys, PSU seems to be the most common culprit (even though the V1000 seemed fine using a voltmeter), ended up buying a Corsair RM650i. Exact same problem (immediate shutdown unless CPU cable unplugged).

Returned the new PSU, bought an Asus Z97 mobo. Transferred the 4770K to new board with CM Hyper 212 EVO and Arctic Silver. Exact same problem.

Am I really looking at a faulty CPU despite the apparently benign circumstances of the first appearance of a problem (Windows reboot while I was sitting there, no strange power spike or otherwise)?
 
Solution
it is extremely unlikely but there is still a small chance of it being possible and by all the information you have given me its the only thing it could be.

Hawkshot

Admirable
honestly it dosent seem like a CPU Failure but it has the potential to be the cause of the problem, would it be possible for you to try the CPU in another computer? also have you tried installing windows again ?
 

ggtriela

Reputable
Nov 3, 2015
5
0
4,510
Unfortunately I don't have access to a 2nd working computer to test the CPU on its own at the moment. I'm unable to install Windows as I can't access my HDs (they've also been unplugged altogether for most of this).
 

Hawkshot

Admirable
if you are seriously getting 1 long beep then 3 short beeps then its the RAM in your computer that is the problem, try taking it out and reinstalling it 1 stick at a time because at least one of them is faulty
 

ggtriela

Reputable
Nov 3, 2015
5
0
4,510
I've tried 1 stick then the other, in all slot configurations. As I said, I'm no longer getting beep codes whatsoever. The problem I'm having now persists even if all RAM is removed completely.
 

ggtriela

Reputable
Nov 3, 2015
5
0
4,510
Yes, I know, and honestly I tried to be careful to include all relevant information in my original post (such as having already tried 1 stick at a time alternating, and no longer getting beep codes); I should clarify what I mean in my last reply, then -

One time I even tried removing all RAM completely:

(a) 1 stick of RAM, immediate shutoff on power, but computer stays on if powering with CPU cable unplugged
(b) NO RAM, immediate shutoff on power, but computer stays on if powering with CPU cable unplugged

I only tried this once, but the problem even appears to be independent of whether RAM is even there at all.
 

Hawkshot

Admirable
oh now I understand, it could be the cpu now that I have this information, it seems that when the CPU gains power it short circuits the board somehow, ive not seen this happen before but ive heard of it I could be that.
 

ggtriela

Reputable
Nov 3, 2015
5
0
4,510
Just my luck, the PSU and mobo appear to be still under warranty and the CPU isn't.. I was just holding out hope since everyone kept saying it was extremely unlikely to be the CPU..

Thanks very much for your responses.