Comparing Old Processors With New

profamous

Honorable
Jun 14, 2012
7
0
10,510
Hey all, been looking to buy/build myself a new computer. It will mostly be used for Windows Server stuff, Active Directory, VPN, NAS file server/family backup, FTP/RDP server, and also as a Plex Media Server. With all this my budget is <~$500.

I'd also like to have a dual monitor setup as well.

I've never built a computer for myself from scratch, and I was looking at Xeon processors.

Not a gamer so I don't need that good of a video card. And I can always add more RAM or hard drives if needed.

Don't know where to start with picking processors, so many different kinds and generations and I need a nudge in the right direction.

I was thinking something along these lines.

I think it's fairly nice, 32 GB RAM and Xeon X5450 processor.

I am just wondering if this processor will be good enough for my needs, I know it is an older one but still a quad core 3 Ghz. Is there any reason to pay a lot more for the newer E3s or E5s? Or should I stick with a standard desktop i7?

Any advice is greatly appreciated!
 

danforthewin

Honorable
Jan 11, 2014
112
0
10,710
If you're not hosting sites or lots of VMs, you don't need that much RAM, or a server processor for that matter. It obviously can't hurt anything, but you could definitely get away with a lot less in a simple home server computer.
Edit: I just read "xeon" and thought server processor. That CPU is actually quite old, and only supports DDR2 memory. You'd be much better off getting a new, low end PC for about the same price.
 

profamous

Honorable
Jun 14, 2012
7
0
10,510
Thank you, that was my thought as well. However, I will be hosting a couple VMs - and I know from my current i5 6GB RAM laptop that I will need a lot of RAM. Just at a loss when it comes to processors...now I am faced with the choice of going with a Xeon E3/E5 or desktop i7/i5? Any thoughts?
 

danforthewin

Honorable
Jan 11, 2014
112
0
10,710


Well, if you have the cash to shell out for an i7 4770k or 4790k, that would probably be your best bang-for-your-buck. Intel i7s have hyperthreading, while the i5s don't (they have dual core hyperthreaded, but that doesn't really help you). Another thing to consider is the most recent generation of Intel processors support DDR4 RAM exclusively, which is new and expensive. Since capacity is a much bigger priority in a server, I would opt for the haswell or broadwell Intels because the RAM will be much cheaper. And now is actually a great time to buy, because it's super cheap at the moment.