Can motherboards cause hardware failure...

mcbeth316

Honorable
Sep 7, 2013
14
0
10,510
or can it be a software issue

To begin I have a 6yrs old alienware aurora(please don't hate...) it has worked well for the most part except for black screen that started round about two years into its life, black screens that went away for months at a time when I reseated the video card and memory (which would often also report as dead)but always came back.

I have over the 6 years upgraded the video card from a 295gtx to a 580gtx.

The 580gtx was RMA'ed for a gtx960 after 2 3/4 years with "artifacting" issues

about a month before the 580 effectively died the hard drive had died and was replaced also.....
so hard drive gone, video card gone both replaced

The same day I installed the 960 windows starts to shutdown the PC abruptly.......... search the event viewer, saw kernel power errors researched that found that the power supply is often the cause of those, bought a power supply even though the existing PSU was meter tested and all the voltages checked out.

Get the new power supply yesterday.....installed, benchmarked and stress tested the hell out of it with rendering projects and benchmark tools and all worked well, open up a browser right after and boom restart this time however display doesn't come up and no system beeps nothing.... fans all running though........research that and all fingers point to the motherboard being dead.....except that after hours of trying to get the computer up and out of morbid curiosity ....and a little self hate I put the thing on while heading to bed and it boots

has anybody ever experienced so many failures so "close" together, along with components reporting dead but then coming back to life?

should I simply gut the PC and replace the board and processor altogether...or is there something I can do to buy some time with this board it's an lga1366 x58...so there really is no replacing that CHEAPLY

thanks
 
Solution
well look over this one and use it to compare others with ?? it a full featured z97 in m-atx ?? maybe a h-board will do ??

http://www.asrock.com/mb/Intel/Z97M%20OC%20Formula/

looks like out of stock- seeing lots of this lately ,but its something to guide by

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813157520

https://pcpartpicker.com/part/asrock-motherboard-z97mocformula

looks like windows 7 is going away as well

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16832416806

[Wal-Mart got it for 200 bucks ?] http://www.walmart.com/ip/Microsoft-Windows-7-Home-Premium-with-SP1-64-bit-Operating-System-PC/36009634


this look interesting and in stock pair it up with a i5 4670/4690...

andrewcarp

Honorable
Sep 10, 2015
21
0
10,540
It sounds like your PSU may have damaged the motherboard/CPU through undervoltage. If you don't want to possibly damage more components, then I would suggest getting a new motherboard and CPU, if not a fresh build altogether.
 

lodders

Admirable
You meter tested your original power supply, and it was OK, so that was not your problem
You fitted a new power supply, and still had issues, so the PSU is absolutely positively not the problem
You have new GPU and HDD, so they are not the problem.

Do you see where this is going?
Before you scrap the motherboard and processor, try updating all the drivers and the BIOS - sometimes fixes big problems
 

Thugginator

Honorable
Feb 2, 2014
75
1
10,660
" I put the thing on "
What does this exactly mean?
Did you turn it on and it worked that time?
Regardless, it does sound like something is wrong with the motherboard.
Many things can keep a computer from POSTING.
So when it comes to an motherboard as old as yours, the problems are already starting to stack up.
I would recommend that you replace the motherboard, because at this rate more problems are going to show them self anyway.
Cheers.
-UPDATE- I also recommend that you replace the CPU as well, Also with your new hardware make sure that the case can support it. So it might also be time to get a new pc case. Good airflow can prolong hardware life.
 
I'd just try a full reinstall if Windows And if you still have issues then pull the board and exam it.

The motherboard is not making your HDD die. But 6 years is a long time. You could have a bad capacitor, heatsink on the VRMs or chipset worked itself lose etc. I've had the heatsink do it on one board that booted very inconsistently.
 

mcbeth316

Honorable
Sep 7, 2013
14
0
10,510


I meant that the computer booted when I turned it on
 

Thugginator

Honorable
Feb 2, 2014
75
1
10,660

Alright.
Keep us updated on the situation.
 

mcbeth316

Honorable
Sep 7, 2013
14
0
10,510


yeah I suspect MB was going to be the likely answer will still try driver and bois updates but a new build might on the cards
 

mcbeth316

Honorable
Sep 7, 2013
14
0
10,510


missed this....yeah I will try this well...exhaust all the options, but in the end even if I get more out of the board ....I think it is the beginning of the end ...if not the end slightly prolonged where the MB is concerned......will be out an OS as well since alienware dell somehow ties the MB to the OS

loved win7 nervous about win10
 
if its just a vid card issue it maybe that old board and the newer cards ?? lok up guys with like z68 boards and how the new 900 cards gave then issues as well for example ?? it was down to the boards bios did not fully support the newer cards at the time so you may want to see if your board has the latest bios on it if they have a recent one to flash to ??
 

mcbeth316

Honorable
Sep 7, 2013
14
0
10,510
one final question can someone who may know recommend mATX board to fit the case and a good CPU, the lights have been off for years anyway so I dont really need anything to support the lights, my budget is thin so yeah recycling as much as I can think the case is R2


thanks again
 
well look over this one and use it to compare others with ?? it a full featured z97 in m-atx ?? maybe a h-board will do ??

http://www.asrock.com/mb/Intel/Z97M%20OC%20Formula/

looks like out of stock- seeing lots of this lately ,but its something to guide by

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813157520

https://pcpartpicker.com/part/asrock-motherboard-z97mocformula

looks like windows 7 is going away as well

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16832416806

[Wal-Mart got it for 200 bucks ?] http://www.walmart.com/ip/Microsoft-Windows-7-Home-Premium-with-SP1-64-bit-Operating-System-PC/36009634


this look interesting and in stock pair it up with a i5 4670/4690

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128716
 
Solution

mcbeth316

Honorable
Sep 7, 2013
14
0
10,510


thanks man much appreciated and thanks to every one else who helped cheers

 

mcbeth316

Honorable
Sep 7, 2013
14
0
10,510
ok final note on this...........if I understand capacitors, from what I have read, they hold and release a charge, the computer now works on first boot for a few hours provide it got "rested" enough and would work for shorter intervals each time it goes down and restarts .......after a while it won't get past the windows logo animation before a forced restart.....then it needs"rest" again, so again, if i understand capacitors. it may bea weak or damaged capacitor.....am I right?
 
well figure the x58 is now like 7 years old so?? then like I said guys with older boards and these newer cards have found compatibility issues . some found there older psu's may not work out as well with the newer cards

use to be you bought stuff that supported what you do now you got to buy stuff to support them