Advice on PC Build + PSU choice

Manos Kli

Reputable
Dec 17, 2015
10
0
4,510
First of all, Hi to all!

I am a new member to your forum but i use to visit as a viewer whenever i was searching for answers for my pc. I can see a really nice community here with great feedback!
Tomorrow i'll sell my old pc for 300 E, i can say that i have an emotional link with it cuz it was my gaming pc for my uni years..but years pass so we have to evolve!
So the good news are that i am going to buy a new one:

Budget:
Around 850E but not strict, i can overcome this ammount if it is necessary but i would like not to.
Time Frame: Until the end of 2015 to purchase all components except GPU which will be bought after3-4 months.

E-shop's url: www.e-shop.gr

Here is my new build:

Case - BitFenix Comrade ATX Midi Tower (39.10 E)
CPU - Intel Core i3-6100 Box (134.5 E)
Motherboard - Asus Z170-K RETAIL ATX LGA1151 (147.50 E)
Memory - Kingston HyperX Fury 8GB 2133MHz DDR4 (56.36 E)
Storage - Samsung 850 EVO 250GB SSD (86.90 E)
Video Card - Saphire ATI Radeon R9 380 Nitro w/BP (260 E)
PSU - 3 options
+ 3 simple fans just enough to cool a bit.



I have dual monitor when working. 1st DELL U24u12m(DVI) , 2nd SAMSUNG 22"(VGA)

Purpose:
MS office, Multitasking (many tabs open RAM in need), and games on decent quality! I dont want extra full graphics, i know i cant really get them with this budget.

Main thought:
To hold this build for some years and upgrade when need comes out. 1st upgrade will be +8GB RAM i think. And MAYBE i'll try Crossfire with a 2nd GPU. Also, i am not interesting in OC.

1. I will buy this GPU in three-four months from now. Until then i want to hold with the intergrated. So can i do that?

2. No, i don't have some other storage inside tower, only one 1TB external disk for backup. I think i can stay with 250 SSD for some time. I was considering about buying M.2 SATA, but its at same price with SSD and half storage capacity.Just to know, without thinking the cost of it, M.2 SATA can be used for main storage disk?

3. With Bitfenix case will i have any space problems inside it with other components?
I would like to have this case, but budget goes up a little bit.
Fractal Design Define S FD-CA-DEF-S-BK Midi Tower no PSU Black (94.40 E)

4. PSU choice:
A. PSU XFX PRO SERIES 650W (97.35 E)
I think it's bronze but a TIER 1 in PSU tier list 2.0 !!??

B. PSU ANTEC EARTHWATTS EA-650 PLATINUM (120 E)
It's a tier 2, but platinum in efficiency.

C. PSU XFX TS SERIES 750W (110 E)
It's a tier2 + bronze, but has 750watts so it can hold the 2nd gpu.

Which of them can hold one and which two GPU's?



That's all! Sorry for this long post but i want to be certain..

Any feedback/suggestions would be great. Thanks in advance.
 
Solution
I'm not Greek, no lol. Scottish & living in Canada. Got some family in Greece though, small village about 45mins from Athens....I forget the name though.

Anyway, back on topic.....Google Translate helps a great deal reading websites in a foreign language.

Honestly, I think it makes the most sense to get the i5 now if your budget can stretch to it..... depending how long you want to keep this particular setup.
The i3 will serve you well, no doubt about it. But in the relatively near future I think the i5 will pull ahead in gaming (it's preferred now anyway) - which would see you needing to upgrade.

Sure the i5 is +80 at the moment, but if you go for the i3 & find yourself needing the i5.....thats going to be +225 or so...

Mac070

Admirable
BANNED
Nice build . The only thing I don't like is the Intel i3 6100. I do believe its skylake . Umm. It will leave you to upgrade later on , if that's yo plan . Otherwise , you could future proof by getting a amd fx 6300 or an I5 and drop the ssd. The i3 won't be sufficient for you needs . It's a dual core cpu which will stutter for gaming . It also won't multitask that well . The fx processor6300 or I5 will be great for that .
 

blasc

Reputable
Nov 21, 2014
769
2
5,360
I can see you are Greek. That is a bad thing when it comes to buying components, since you can get the parts cheaper if you order them from abroad.

So before I suggest other options I would like to ask you if you are willing to order the parts online and from other country? That way I can give you the full suggestions based on the price/budget you mentioned.

Btw, I'm from Portugal, and I made my build this summer, with the parts coming from all around Europe :)
 

Barty1884

Retired Moderator
The build is decent. The i3-6100 is Skylake as far as I know? The i3-6320 would be the best of the i3's though, and sufficient for gaming. http://techreport.com/news/28957/the-skylake-core-i3-6320-is-the-gamer-new-best-friend

An i5 would be perfect for you....the i5-6400 (2.7Ghz) is 80EUR more, whereas the i5-6500 (3.2Ghz) is 100EUR more. That would be the sweet spot in my opinion. You'll need to upgrade from the i3 in future, so grabbing the i5 now makes the most sense financially.

The i3 should be fine for gaming, it's dual core with hyperthreading - but depending on the number of takss you want to be running at the same time, that may falter slightly.

As far as the PSU goes, efficiency isn't really anything to worry about as the price difference between bronze & platinum takes a long time to pay itself off in energy savings.
Tier 2 or better is perfect for your rig, so any of the options you selected will serve you just fine. Pick the one that's cheapest....and prefer modular vs non or semi modular.
 

Manos Kli

Reputable
Dec 17, 2015
10
0
4,510
#Mac070
Thanks for your answer. Yes, i3-6100 is a skylake. I plan to upgrade it after2-3 years and change a processor. i56400 is 70-80 E over i3-6100, and i cant really drop SSD cuz its my only storage unit inside case. External disk is for backup only.

#blasc
Thanx! As our banks have capital controls, things are little difficult buying from abroad. There are ways but is difficult. So before you suggest me your options, how cheaper % do you think it will be in total? (+ shipping costs)

In the listing prices above there is a 7% discount total cuz of different VAT from place to place inside Greece. :) So how much cheaper can they be?
Thanks in advance.
 

Barty1884

Retired Moderator
Not sure if this will post properly but:
pic.png
[/url]
image hosting[/img]
 

Manos Kli

Reputable
Dec 17, 2015
10
0
4,510


#barty1984
Thanks for your answer.
I wont have Heavy multitasking. and i think that i3-6100 is better from i5-6400 in gaming?Or not?

PSU: They are all full wired non modular. So i'll fight with the cables!!
I asked more about the 1 or 2 GPU units that i am thinking to place. Will for example the 650W pSU hold my system with 2 x GPU R9380?
 

Manos Kli

Reputable
Dec 17, 2015
10
0
4,510


Answered above.
 

Manos Kli

Reputable
Dec 17, 2015
10
0
4,510


Hope this does not consider as spam..

Answered above.
 

Barty1884

Retired Moderator
For power, a rough estimation for your rig would be 65W for CPU, 190W for each GPU (so 380W for CrossFire) + around 100W for the balance of your rig.

That puts you at 545W at absolute max load (which you'll rarely do), with no OC potential in your rig. so a 650W or 750W PSU would be fine (provided it's a quality unit, which all 3 you picked are).

For a single GPU even a 500W PSU would be fine.

An i5 would perform better overall. On some games the i3 would likely perform just as well as the i5, but it'll never perform better. And certain games it'll perform worse.

I've posted a build from your preferred website above as an idea. It does go over you budget, but would last you a lot longer.
 

Manos Kli

Reputable
Dec 17, 2015
10
0
4,510


Nice Barty1984!
Tell me the truth you are from greece? Didnt you found difficulties by reading Greek? lol just kidding.
Yes that's the price! 932.
Do you think that a processor change is necessary? i3-6320 is +50 and i5-6400 is +80.
 

Manos Kli

Reputable
Dec 17, 2015
10
0
4,510


For PSU, now i understand what you meant about picking the cheapest of three options.
Well there is an offer for a seasonic PSU tier 2 psu-seasonic-m12ii-520-bronze-520w/url] for only 70 EUR, but it will not hold the second gpu when placed.
Thanks for all your answers. Much appreciated.
 

Barty1884

Retired Moderator
I'm not Greek, no lol. Scottish & living in Canada. Got some family in Greece though, small village about 45mins from Athens....I forget the name though.

Anyway, back on topic.....Google Translate helps a great deal reading websites in a foreign language.

Honestly, I think it makes the most sense to get the i5 now if your budget can stretch to it..... depending how long you want to keep this particular setup.
The i3 will serve you well, no doubt about it. But in the relatively near future I think the i5 will pull ahead in gaming (it's preferred now anyway) - which would see you needing to upgrade.

Sure the i5 is +80 at the moment, but if you go for the i3 & find yourself needing the i5.....thats going to be +225 or so (luckily the rest of the rig supports it already). It's totally your call afterall, so pick whichever you think will work for you. If you plan on building a new rig in the next year or two, then yo ucan grab an i5 then.......if however you're the kind of person who will use this rig for 2-5 years, I think the i5 would be a great investment.

As far as the PSU goes, the SeaSonic PSU will work well.......but you're correct, once/if you add a second GPU, you're then having to upgrade your PSU also.

Difficult decision, I appreciate that. But another 80 for the CPU and 50 or so for the PSU is only another 130.............if you have to upgrade those two down the road a bit, that's more like 250 at that time.
 
Solution

blasc

Reputable
Nov 21, 2014
769
2
5,360
sory for the delay.

For 850€ you can EASILY get a better rig than that. Problem is, like i said before, you need to order from abroad (you can even order from Amazon). Specially if you don't need monitor and HDD.

Regarding specific components:
CPU: getting an i3 for the build you are planning is a mistake. You will want (and maybe even NEED) to upgrade to the i5, and by upgrading, you will be losing money. So the best and smart option, is to get an i5 from the start. It may be more expensive now, but with the i3 you will be losing money in the long run (even more, since the i3 will lose its value way faster).
GPU: http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/answers/id-2838758/390-crossfire-380.html
I wouldn't go with the crossfire. Better option would be to get the 390 instead of future Crossfire.
PSU: With the single card, you won't need so much power. More options for better prices. Also, since you are not overclocking nor tweaking, and as long you get a PSU with enough juice, the PSU can be tier 2b, or even tier 3. There will be no harm in that. You want higher quality when you are overclocking your components, or when you are pulling a very high percentage of the PSU's advertised wattage (using it near the limit, not recommended lol). As long as the PSU's parts are of reliable production (tier 3 and up) there will be no prob.
RAM: If you are planning on getting 8GB and +8GB later, I recommend getting only 1x8GB stick now, and later, get an exact same model of the one you get now, instead of the 2x4GB now. Less load on the CPU that way.
Storage:Don't get the M.2. No need for that with the use you are planning on doing.

Now for the components list, I will post first the list with the prices from your store (http://www.e-shop.gr), and then the same list with prices from stores around the web, so you can see the difference:

GREEK STORE:
PCPartPicker part list

CPU: Intel Core i5-6500 3.2GHz Quad-Core Processor (€230.00)
CPU Cooler: Cooler Master Hyper 212 EVO 82.9 CFM Sleeve Bearing CPU Cooler (€40.00)
Motherboard: Gigabyte GA-Z170-HD3P ATX LGA1151 Motherboard (€145.00)
Memory: Corsair 8GB (1 x 8GB) DDR4-2133 Memory (€56.00)
Storage: Samsung 850 EVO-Series 250GB 2.5" Solid State Drive (€87.00)
Video Card: Asus Radeon R9 390 8GB Video Card (€445.00)
Case: BitFenix Comrade ATX Mid Tower Case (€40.00)
Power Supply: SeaSonic M12II 650W 80+ Bronze Certified Semi-Modular ATX Power Supply (€90.00)
Total: €1133.00


http://www.pccomponentes.com - SPANISH WEBSITE (im at work, so i just searched here. Reliable site since i ordered some parts here. You can search around the web for other Europe stores, like Germany, UK, etc):
PCPartPicker part list / Price breakdown by merchant

CPU: Intel Core i5-6500 3.2GHz Quad-Core Processor (€210.00)
CPU Cooler: Cooler Master Hyper 212 EVO 82.9 CFM Sleeve Bearing CPU Cooler (€30.00)
Motherboard: Gigabyte GA-Z170-HD3P ATX LGA1151 Motherboard (€124.00)
Memory: Corsair 8GB (1 x 8GB) DDR4-2133 Memory (€56.00)
Storage: Samsung 850 EVO-Series 250GB 2.5" Solid State Drive (€80.00)
Video Card: Asus Radeon R9 390 8GB Video Card (€380.00)
Case: BitFenix Comrade ATX Mid Tower Case (€34.00)
Power Supply: SeaSonic S12II 620W 80+ Bronze Certified ATX Power Supply (€80.00)
Total: €994.00



so as you can see, just going to 1 single different store, I managed to put a much superior GPU and CPU in the build, with the price going only 150€ above your budget. You can still cut down on RAM, SSD, case and Amazon has much cheaper PSUs around for the same quality.

My point is that, with 850€, and doing the right research, you can get a much better build that you were thinking of. Also, I repeat the fact that you should go for the single GPU from the start, instead of planning for a future crossfire. The same goes for the CPU. You should go for the i5 from the start. If you still dont have €€, then i advise you wait and save a bit more (maybe 2 months will be enough?), and then get these components. If you are aiming for this level of computer, you should get components that won't lose their value on the long run, while at the same time will last for years to come while being used.

That way, if you ever feel the need or think you want to get better stuff, their value remains. But if you want to stick with them, they won't let you down no matter what you throw at them.


Finally, if you REALLY are on budget, then my recommendation will be to go with Haswell, since it is still pretty much alive, and will be for the next ~4 (my guess) years.
 

Barty1884

Retired Moderator
I agree with some/most of what blasc has said (or did he agree with me? I don't know) but anyway.....if you can order from abroad cheaply, then do so. But between shipping & VAT (I've heard Greece has some pretty crazy import/customs laws and it's like 30% VAT if imported from EU countries on items greater than 45EUR? I don't know that for sure) that could totally kill a budget.


Blasc's given you pretty much the same build I did, with a change in board & GPU. I think the boards are fairly equal, so either/or would work. The GPU though, I agree in principal with buying the better card rather than planning to CF in future......but you said you might CF. The 380 will be more than sufficient for you.....and if you choose to CF, then do so.

The PSU....ah, the PSU. Personally I suggest you stick with Tier 1 or 2. This sounds like a sizeable purchase for you, so don't risk it by putting a lesser quality PSU in. 750W it overkill, but will allow you to CF in future if you decide to.
If you go with a lower capacity PSU now, that'll just mean a PSU upgrade along with a new GPU should you decide to.
For around 25EUR more, I think it's totally worth it. It won't cost you any more in utilities (as the PSU will only 'pull' what it needs), so I think that's your best option.

As far as RAM goes......2x4GB would be your best bet over 1x8GB. Both boards have 4 DIMM slots, so it's not like you have to save your space. 4x4GB in future will put you at 16GB, and nothing is going to need more than that in the lifespan of this PC. As far as putting less stress on the CPU............I've never heard that claim for anything with a remotely decent CPU. If you go with the i5, 2x4GB running in dual-channel will perform better than 1x8GB single channel.
 

Manos Kli

Reputable
Dec 17, 2015
10
0
4,510
#Barty1884 , #blasc
Sorry for the delay, we drove me into thoughts these days.
Well.. each of you has different prospect.
Thanks a lot for your answers.
I have some good news and one a little bad.
The bad one is that the purchase will be postponed for about 1 month, the good news is that i found a great discount equal to 1/4.
Also there is a site that conpares eshops values all over the country http://skroutz.gr
There are plenty of shops there with better prices than eshop.gr. Either way i have 1 month to consider my build again and decide the online shop that i'll purchase from.

Blasc i think i'll not buy from abroad since i found that discount + free shiping :) !! Anyway thanks for your help!

Barty i knew that there are some greek genes inside you, LoL!
There are restrictions in Greece that almost do not let you to buy from abroad..

Back to the main subject,
About RAM: I'll start with 1x8GB and then after some months i'll upgrade to dual channel, same RAM, +1x8GB.

About CPU:I'll follow your advices and ,i'll place an i5-6500 processor into my build.

About GPU: There will be a placement of 1GPU with more power as you suggested, i'll not crossfire. Probably the card will be Saphire R9 390 8GB nitro http://r9 390!! but i am not preety sure if this is a good option over r9 380 4GB for the money. !?

About PSU: There will be a good quality Tier 1.0 or 2.0 550W or 650W. Even with Saphire R9 390 8GB nitro, can a PSU at 520 or 550W, hold my rig? I think R9 390 has 275W.


Now About MOBO: i was thinking that if i only 1 GPU + the fact that a total of 16GB of RAM will cover my needs in Pc's lifespan as Barty1884 suggested, i dont really need mobo Z170.
An Asus H110 would be a good choice? There are different series over H110 and i dont really know which one to choose... And there are at almost half price to Z170.
In general It's an microATX with ATX form factor, is this compatible with all of my components?