Computer system comparison - Keep old or buy new? Need advice!

nitebane21

Distinguished
Sep 26, 2011
14
0
18,510
I'm trying to figure out if its worth upgrading my old computer to Windows 10 or if this new computer is better. I do a decent amount of online gaming but don't mind running low to medium graphics though I really prefer to play at 1920x1080 resolution.

Old computer - Dell XPS 630i
Upgraded video card to Nvidia GeForce GTX 285
Ram is 4x 2gb DDR2 sticks
More specs can be found here: http://www.pcworld.com/product/32040/xps-630-desktop-customizable.html

New computer - Lenovo H50 - A10
Specs can be found here: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16883798515

I'm concerned about the small power supply size in the Lenovo (only 180W). Some have also reported that the motherboard can only support 6gb of ram per slot (comes with an 8GB and 2GB stick) so you're really only getting 10GB of ram. On the other hand, quad core processor, graphics cards that was not made in 2009 and DD3 vs DDR2 ram.

The new computer is $400, the old one needs me to purchase a new copy of Windows, which would be Windows 10 at $120. Should I stick with the old and put Win 10 on it or go with the new and retire the XPS?
 

hiyabusared

Reputable
Dec 24, 2015
607
0
5,360
Spend the extra money and upgrade to the new. Reason being your old rig everything is just getting very old mind you the core 2 duo is still a good cpu imo. DDr2 to DDr3 is a drastic improvement, the cpu is a gigantic jump in performance and speed, the graphics card is just far superior. I would get the new system and use the old as a server for your household or even use it for servers on TS etc.
 

meaga1n

Reputable
Dec 22, 2015
189
0
4,760
+1 for the above.
I moved from almost exactly the same spec (- the gpu) to a newer AMD and the difference is huge. I would personally go Intel but for the money that looks great.

ONLY THING: That has integrated graphics so will be a lot slower than your 285. You could possibly upgrade the PSU (or swap with the Dell) and then put in your 285 into the new Lenovo...?
 

nitebane21

Distinguished
Sep 26, 2011
14
0
18,510
Ok, I was concerned about the integrated graphics but I would need to swap the PSU to swap the video card. Surprised a low end card fro 2009 still beats an integrated one!
 

nitebane21

Distinguished
Sep 26, 2011
14
0
18,510
Ok, so this JUST went on sale on Amazon for the same $399 price point. http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=9784315

Pros:
350W power supply
16GB memory (and each slot can support it, unlike the Lenovo)

Cons:
Worse integrated graphics card (but easier to swap PSUs)
Liquid-cooled AMD A4-6300 3.70 GHz Dual-Core Processor - Is this better or worse than the AMD A10-7800 3.5 GHz Quad-Core?
 

nitebane21

Distinguished
Sep 26, 2011
14
0
18,510
Thanks for the info, but I need a PC for work and my current one's OS is barely hanging by a thread so I figure either $120 for Win 10 or $400 for a new system with Win 10 already on it. Plus by the time I get a mobo/cpu combo, new ram and a new OS I'm probably at or over the $400 mark anyways.

It's looking like I'll get the new system, a 24 to 14 pin adapter cable and reuse the old systems PSU and graphics card. Best of both worlds!