Question about JBOD configuration (linear vs non-linear)

A Furry Peanut

Honorable
Jan 11, 2016
44
0
10,530
So I am planning on getting WD My Book Duo 4TB and it is basically an enclosure that comes with two 2 TB internal hard drives and according to Western Digital they come configured in RAID 0 but with an option for RAID 1 and JBOD.
So after some research I noticed that JBOD seems to have two meanings that contradict each other, one is that JBOD will see all its physical drives as a single drive, so using my product as an example, my computer would see it as a 4 TB drive, but the other meaning is that JBOD, unlike RAID configurations, are seen as separate drives so instead of my computer seeing it as a 4 TB drive, it will see it as two 2 TB drives. So I'm just wondering as to what's going on here.

My Book Duo will contain two physical drives, and for the first drive I would like to store my videos on it, and for the second drive I would like to use it as a back up for the videos on my first drive. I know having it in RAID 1 will do just that, however, I'm also worried about corrupted files, accidental deletes, and viruses so I would like to have my back-up drive update every night to give me a chance to fix any data problems as apposed to having a complete mirror which wouldn't allow me to do such a thing. 
So I guess my other question is: How do I make sure my JBOD is configured as two separate physical drives
 
Solution
Well whatever they maybe, it's saying the user has the freedom to choose any all the 3 configurations. Don't worry about the terminology so much. Assuming you are buying with TWO 2TB drives.

Option 1. (plain) JBOD - Windows will see two separate drives. 4tb total storage split in two drive letters, C: and D: (?)
Option 2. RAID0 - WD combines it for you and Windows see a single drive letter. Still 4tb total storage.
Option 3. RAID1 - mirrors drives to guard against single drive failure. Total storage 2tb in a single drive letter.

RAID is not a replacement for Backup, so for your specific requirement, pick Option 1, and use the second drive for backup.

Best Practice Tip: A backup drive should really be a physically separate unit...
Well whatever they maybe, it's saying the user has the freedom to choose any all the 3 configurations. Don't worry about the terminology so much. Assuming you are buying with TWO 2TB drives.

Option 1. (plain) JBOD - Windows will see two separate drives. 4tb total storage split in two drive letters, C: and D: (?)
Option 2. RAID0 - WD combines it for you and Windows see a single drive letter. Still 4tb total storage.
Option 3. RAID1 - mirrors drives to guard against single drive failure. Total storage 2tb in a single drive letter.

RAID is not a replacement for Backup, so for your specific requirement, pick Option 1, and use the second drive for backup.

Best Practice Tip: A backup drive should really be a physically separate unit apart from the production unit, and ideally powered down or taken offline when not doing backup. Following your thinking, if the backup drive is constantly on and visible to your system, "things," intentional or otherwise may corrupt your backup drive which defeats the purpose of a backup. If you are able to take the backup drive offline, after your backup procedure, whether you need to physically pull the drive out from its enclosure, will somewhat complies with this Best Practice.
 
Solution