The EVGA will be fine.
Somehow you managed to sneak by w/o killing the +12V rail on that Gigabyte PSU. The GTX 760 at 100% usage drew ~15 amps from the +12V rail. The OC'ed i7 drew another 8 to 10 amps. That left ~11 amps for the rest of the components in your system. And that is if the PSU was 100% efficient. Of course, it wasn't. More like 80% efficient. You got lucky.
The 980 Ti is a 250W card. That means it will draw somewhere in the neighborhood of 21A from the +12V rail when it reaches 100% usage.