Welcome to the TH community, ATPhillips!
I'd recommend you to try using a different SATA port with the WD Blue and also try plugging it with a different SATA cable. I'd also suggest you go to your motherboard manufacturer's website and make sure you have the latest SATA controller and chipset drivers for your model. Giving the
BIOS reset a try might also be a good idea, it would get your BIOS settings back to factory defaults which could help with the proper detection of the HDD.
Hope it helps. Keep us posted!
SuperSoph_WD