USB 3.0 HDD file sharing (and/or backups) over n wifi

jjbirky

Reputable
Feb 19, 2016
8
0
4,510
I've got a new usb 3.0 External HDD that I plan to attach to my router, to be used for itunes sharing and backups.

My current router is the WD mynet n750. It'll work, but it doesn't support usb 3.0, so I'm considering upgrading to a router with usb 3.0 and the ac-wifi that'd come with it. Thing is... both of our laptops are only n-wifi compatable. So I'm not sure we'd even immediately benefit from the faster speeds of either ac-wifi OR usb 3.0.

There are a couple other reasons I'm considering a new router anyway (print server support for mac; better NAS support; better range), but it'd be nice to know if I'd be paying for immediate performance/speed boosts, or just those other less-important reasons.

Also quick note: just did a read/write speed test on my laptop's internal HDD if that might also be a potential bottleneck. Screenshot of results here: http://screencast.com/t/d0SrGczNU

Thanks for any feedback!
 
Solution
A HD attached to a router is really a "poor man" NAS. Forget about getting 92 MBYTE/S, you may get 60 MBYTE or even less. Do you think USB3, BAM! automatically pump you up to 500 MBYTE class access, MOST CERTAINLY NOT. Read the reviews on the new router you want to buy and get the actual thruput number from actual users' tests, because the vendor don't disclose this information.

But hey it's easy and you may not need more than 20 MBYTE/S in real life.

Another thing you want to find out it what drive format will the router support. NTFS best, eFAT second best, anything else you will have problem accessing large video files.
A HD attached to a router is really a "poor man" NAS. Forget about getting 92 MBYTE/S, you may get 60 MBYTE or even less. Do you think USB3, BAM! automatically pump you up to 500 MBYTE class access, MOST CERTAINLY NOT. Read the reviews on the new router you want to buy and get the actual thruput number from actual users' tests, because the vendor don't disclose this information.

But hey it's easy and you may not need more than 20 MBYTE/S in real life.

Another thing you want to find out it what drive format will the router support. NTFS best, eFAT second best, anything else you will have problem accessing large video files.
 
Solution

TRENDING THREADS