Sabertooth Z170 Overclocking RAM and CPU

bmcelvan

Distinguished
Jan 8, 2015
69
0
18,640
I recently built my new rig in a CM Storm Stryker (although why the storm trooper is black and the white case is called something else I'll never understand) and have a couple of questions specifically about overclocking the RAM and CPU on this motherboard and some of the issues I've had in doing so. Components as follows:

ASUS Sabertooth Z170 Mark1
Intel i7-6700k
G.Skill Tridentz 3200MHz 32GB (2x16GB) 15-15-15-35 RAM
CM Hyper 612 v2 air cooler
SanDisk 240GB SATA III SSD PLUS
2 Other SATA HDDs, 750GB and 1.5TB
Firstly, Ultra X4 750W PSU then HydroG 750W PSU
Win8.1_64bit

I was first using an Ultra X4 750W Modular PSU. When I first started the new computer using bios version 1101 (10/23/2015) I was able to turn on X.M.P and load into windows. CPU-Z read 1600MHz so I thought I was all good. Upon further use, basically adding the drivers and updating windows which has lots of restarts I noticed it would almost never restart or shut down properly. 1 in 5-10 times it would properly restart or shut down. I would then have to hold down the power key until it shut off, turn the power back on (about a 25% chance here of getting an "overclock failure" error message when booting up) go into bios and then restart from there and would load into windows okay showing 1600MHz. Lastly, I updated the bios to the most recent version 1602 01/01/2016) and it wouldn't even post. Just gave me the 4 beeps in a row ASUS hardware failure notification. So I put the bios back to 1101 and used until I made my next move.

After reading a lot of reviews about how bad Ultra is, reading your report of quality PSUs and thinking back to my old computer where the PSU came from and how it would never load into windows the first try, it would always freeze and shut down at the Win8 rotating circles load screen on first go and then would ALWAYS finally load on second go, I ordered and installed last night a FSP Group HydroG 750W PSU. With this PSU, NO VERSION of the bios will post with X.M.P. enabled which pissed me off, but in trying to work around that I manually changed the bios settings for DRAM voltage to 1.35V, the speed to DDR4 3000 and the timing to 14, 14, and 34. The sync all cores was already selected, seems to be default. And I kept the Ai Overclock Tuner on Auto. These settings seem to work fine and I have no problems with restarting and shutting down or hibernating thus far, only been one night.

Question 1:
My first question is about overclocking the RAM. Is it safe to reduce the latency as far as it will go while still posting and seemingly running okay? Or could this potentially reduce the lifespan of the RAM or damage it in any way? I used the 3000@14-14-34 settings based on the idea that the cycle time (9.33ns) is nearly identical to its actual G.Skill verified rating of 3200@15-15-35 (9.375ns).

Question 2:
Could increasing the voltage over 1.35V for the RAM potentially get the 3200MHz to work. That's over G.Skill rating so is that a bad idea?

Question 3:
I plan on overclocking my CPU as well. Should I do that first, optimize it and then overclock the RAM after the CPU? Or if I consider the overclocked RAM more important then the CPU, should I OC the CPU with the already overclocked RAM?

Question 4:
For overclocking the CPU, I was going to:
Ai Overclock Tuner--> Manual
Sync All Cores
Change the 1-core value to 45 (which should change all cores since synced right?)
Change the CPU Core/Cache Voltage to manual mode (should I use adaptive right off?) and change to 1.35V.
Save and restart and if it posts, test stability using Realbench and checking my temps to make sure they stay at or below 80°C when maxed out under load.
If all goes well and is stable, change CPU Core/Cache Voltage to Adaptive and change Additional Turbo Mode CPU Core Voltage to 1.37V. (+0.2V over CPU core Voltage).

Question 5:
Any idea why the supposedly great sever grade components Gold certified PSU won't let the RAM go to 3200MHz where the supposedly crappy un-steady PSU would?

Any help on this is a big thanks.

Ben
 

Tradesman1

Legenda in Aeternum
With the DRAM, make sure you have the latest BIOS, then enable XMP, profile 1 and see if it works. If not you may need a small OC on the CPU.

So, try a small OC on the CPU first, then set the DRAM up using XMP, if it appears stable, then can try OCing the CPU higher and leave the DRAM alone.

All the Gold really means is that the PSU is very effective at taking the input power and effectively disbursing it (not to mention the PSU might be flaky or going bad, even when brand new)
 

bmcelvan

Distinguished
Jan 8, 2015
69
0
18,640
I enabled just X.M.P with the bios version it came with (the one that worked with the Ultra PSU with X.M.P. enabled) and the most recent version (didn't work with Ultra PSU).

DOES NOT POST for either version (4 beeps from the mobo speaker and when restarted gives error "overclock fail, re-enter bios settings).

Without any RAM oveclocking, changed CPU Core/Cache Voltage to manual @ 1.35V, synced all cores and changed 1-core value to 43 and then I also did 45. Ran RealBench benchmark and the temps never went above 75°C for either value.

Restarted, entered bios, enabled X.M.P at both the 43 and 45 values and got the same result. DOES NOT POST and gives overclock failure error.

I also tried 3200_15-15-35@1.35V and 3200_16-16-36@1.35V without enabling X.M.P. and got same result.

It appears this board does not like the speed of 3200, with this RAM kit anyway.

Is it okay to reduce the latency value as far as it will go so long as it posts and loads into windows or can this damage the RAM?

Can I go above the 1.35V for RAM? Or is that not recommended?

thx
 

bmcelvan

Distinguished
Jan 8, 2015
69
0
18,640


I was wondering that after purchasing the memory, if you look at the attached image (memory QVL Jan2016) it looks like at 3200 they have nothing listed at 32GB at all and don't even have 8GB sticks listed. And no timings under 16-16-16-36.

At 3000 they have 8GB sticks listed and they have two 32GB options both with 8 GB sticks.

I think I'll stick with the 3000 until new bios comes out and check then. I'm not holding my breath.

I'll play with the 1.4V option to see if it even works but I don't think I'd want to run them at that, given I have an air cooler. Won't that effectively bring down the OC I can get away with on my CPU (meaning it be drawing more power and more heat).
Sabertooth%20Z170%20Memory%20QVL%20Jan2016.png
 

bmcelvan

Distinguished
Jan 8, 2015
69
0
18,640


Had another thought...I don't know much about the system voltage agent or VCCIO but read in Dee@myce overclocking post that RAM overclocking at 3200 and over can be hard so these need to be modified. Then I read somewhere else that the system voltage agent should never be changed off auto. Think these might make the difference? Any advice on values so I don't damage CPU if it's even worth a try?
 

Tradesman1

Legenda in Aeternum
VCCIO is adjustable (also often called the CPUVTT or DDRVTT) it feeds your MC (memory controller) and is useful in stabilizing DRAM. I think best to start with the DRAM voltgae before wandering into the the MC voltage. OCing the CPU can also help. VCCSA on this platform is sort of a last resort, that's more oriented to X97/X99 and some individual mobos where they combined the MC voltage into the system agent voltage (i.e. Asus did this with many 1155 mobos)
 

bmcelvan

Distinguished
Jan 8, 2015
69
0
18,640


Should I try a combination of VCCIO and DRAM at the same time or try them independently?

Is it safe to go all the way up to 1.2V for the VCCIO...where should I stop?

thx again

 

justgjt

Commendable
May 1, 2016
11
0
1,510
Did you end up getting it sorted out....
I am about to order my memory for the same motherboard and CPU.

If so, what was the solution ?

Thanks : )
 

markm75

Distinguished
Mar 21, 2007
51
1
18,535
Curious on the answer as well.. it sounds as if the sabertooth doesnt overclock as well as say the base asus Z170-A for ram? Specs wise it only lists 2400mhz as the max ddr4.. the z170-A lists a bunch of OC values.. has me leaning towards just getting 2600mhz ram and maybe the sabertooth, or faster ram and maybe the z1070-a.. unsure.