Is Windows Vista as bad as it's said to be?

AtomicGPU

Reputable
Oct 9, 2014
43
0
4,540
Hello.

Windows Vista has a teribble reputation. It had many issues, especailly back in 2007. But, quiet frankly, I've actully heard that it has gotten better after several updates.

I have an older PC that I'd like to use it on, mainly because that's the only OS I have for it...that and Windows XP.

I would like to know: How stable is it; does it restrict performance, if so how much from that of 7 or XP; other reasons to have; others not to have it. Is better to use Vista, or the outdated and unsupported Windows XP? Keep in mind this isn't for my main PC.

Thank You.
 
Solution
Vista was rushed out after the disaster of Win Me.
It got a hugely bad rep on release. Most of that was due to bad drivers, and a published minimum requirement that was too low. Systems ran like crap.
But also, the overly restrictive UAC. It prompted ALL the time.

No to XP.
Extended support for Vista ends April 2017. So it will be in the same boat as XP is now.

What will you be using this system for? Maybe a flavor of Linux would work well.

SKIPPY PB

Reputable
Jan 9, 2015
486
0
4,860
I run Windows 7 and XP personally. I have no problems with XP, it can browse the internet just like any other set up and does what it does well. I have no personal experiance with Vista but I don't really think it can be THAT bad espiecally now depending on what you have to do with it. I still love windows XP so im biased. Im not cry about the fact it wont play some new triple A game of tomorrow. Excel works, word, internet, email, and the programs I want on it work, etc. Only thing is newer software will outrun in, things like browser updates and flash player type things can be tricky to deal with. You have to understand that and accept it before going in. If you acknowledge this and proceed with caution i would think you will be alright. Although again I have no personal experience with the OS.
 

USAFRet

Titan
Moderator
Vista was rushed out after the disaster of Win Me.
It got a hugely bad rep on release. Most of that was due to bad drivers, and a published minimum requirement that was too low. Systems ran like crap.
But also, the overly restrictive UAC. It prompted ALL the time.

No to XP.
Extended support for Vista ends April 2017. So it will be in the same boat as XP is now.

What will you be using this system for? Maybe a flavor of Linux would work well.
 
Solution

AtomicGPU

Reputable
Oct 9, 2014
43
0
4,540


Nothing much. Just an extra PC, I'll use it for whatever when I need it.
 

USAFRet

Titan
Moderator


Might be a good time to learn Linux.
 


There are two sides to this story: Actual Vista Issues, and the circumstances of its release.



---1) The Vista RTM was buggy, but the service packs did resolve most of the bugs. The current version is stable.

---2) Most of the "driver issues" were simply the fact that Microsoft made major changes to the driver model that broke compatibility with XP/2000 drivers. Windows 7, 8, and 10, continue to have this issue, but even if a windows 10 driver isn't available, 90 percent of the time, the 7 or 8 works because the basic driver model has not changed a whole lot since Vista. So, Vista was hurt here by circumstances beyond its control. Windows 7 would have had the same problem, if it had been released before Vista.

----3) Performance issues were part Vista's fault, and part circumstance. Vista really is the slowest version of windows of all time. However, at the time of is release, the average processor was less than half as fast as the processors during the release of Windows 7. Average memory also tripled during that time. If Vista had launched with Phenom X4 and Core 2 quad machines with 3gb of ram on the entry level machines, instead of Pentium D's and Athlon X2's with 1gb of ram, the perception of Vista would likely have been a good deal better than it was.

----4) Look and feel was another thing that hurt Vista. It looked terrible, just like windows 10 does. The dark, poorly thought out, default theme, turned a lot of users off. People don't want to be depressed looking at their PC. Yes, you could change it, but many people didn't want to be bothered or just didn't know how.

----5) It was released on the heals of Windows XP, the greatest Microsoft OS of all time, while it was in its prime. XP was still receiving full support and full feature and security upgrades. And it had none of the shortcomings I just listed for Vista.



When you consider the totality of the circumstances, along with Vista's shortcomings, its not a surprise that it took a beating in the eyes of public opinion. But in spite of all those issues, it did mature into a respectable operating system.