NEW Workstation , Pc or server ? Need advice

boris888

Commendable
Apr 7, 2016
9
0
1,510
Hi Guys,

In about 2-3 months I am planning to get a new workstation that will serve as a workhorse for my 2D work (Photoshop) , 3D work (Alias software mainly) and rendering work ( Keyshot & possibly VRED), I will also use it for Adobe AE which needs quite a lot of RAM.

Nevertheless main requirements I would say are best CPU power as possible for the budget and a lot of RAM(upto 192 max i believe, but probably 64 or 128 might be enough too). I am not sure about the GPU what kind of card would a need but as far as i know for example Keyshot is CPU based anyway. From my knowledge I know i would need a decent card just to run those software's and up-to 4 monitors.

I would also need some decent SSD as a primary hard drive and possible just a secondary big HHD ( for archive)

What is needed is only the workstation all other stuff like monitors and other accessories i got.

Budget is about : 5-7K GBP so about 7000-10000$ ( obviously I would prefer the options closer to the 5000GBP as im not totally sure if i can stretch all the way to 7000GBP).

I did a small research by myself on various workstation providers, and it just seems that usually their configurations are a bit overpriced comparing to the component prices and just wondered if it might be cheaper just to build this new beast by myself. My current workstation was build with the help of my friend just by gathering components and putting them together and it did work fine for all those years so far. the only worry would be that I wont have any warranty then and if I want to spend so much money on this beast possibly would be better to be more secure if something goes wrong.

Moreover I am slightly confused , should i buy just a normal PC or maybe think of a RACK system ?
What do you think guys ? and what advantages or disadvantages do you see in both ?


Please do let me know what are your suggestions and opinions, as I am not a hardware specialist so I bet you will have a better understanding how I can get best possible machine for that budget.

Thank you in advance for every sensible response.






 
Solution
There are so many ways to make this happen that you can get lost in the forest.

You already have a use case. A description of your work flow would be of some help.
How do you do things and in what order and so on, stuff like how big your files are
and the resolution you want to work in and if 10 bit is necessary.

Another thing that is important is exactly what you are using now, how it is
performing and what you would like your upgraded system to be able to do.
This will ensure that you get a bang out of your buck instead of just getting
more of the same with an almost lateral upgrade.

When you get that information into the light then you can look at the difference
in performance a dual CPU system would make and what processors to...

frapport

Honorable
Dec 2, 2015
108
0
10,760
There are so many ways to make this happen that you can get lost in the forest.

You already have a use case. A description of your work flow would be of some help.
How do you do things and in what order and so on, stuff like how big your files are
and the resolution you want to work in and if 10 bit is necessary.

Another thing that is important is exactly what you are using now, how it is
performing and what you would like your upgraded system to be able to do.
This will ensure that you get a bang out of your buck instead of just getting
more of the same with an almost lateral upgrade.

When you get that information into the light then you can look at the difference
in performance a dual CPU system would make and what processors to put into
something like that or whether you need a fast CPU with less cores and a larger
graphical solution like a workstation quadro or firepro.

Some of the general things that should be considered for lack of onsite machine
warranty is the quality of the parts. Your current machine has obviously served
you well and electronics have only gotten more efficient and reliable.

A rackmount system would be more akin to your personal render farm. I get
the sense that you need something that moves in close to real time which in
turn makes your process faster, quicker iterations and faster renders. It's
when your business or workload gets so big that you are considering racks
then perhaps you should just be renting cloud time at that point.

I'm sure that you could get a number of different suggestions for configurations
going off just what you have mentioned but I'd like to hear about your actual process
and solve from there. Each variable can then be weighed against the various options
and price/capacity/speed and so on balanced within the system build. And for that kind
of money I'd also like to see a major bump in speed and capacity for throughput.
 
Solution