Elpida memory won't work at all in Asus Crosshair II motherboard

coolinventor

Commendable
Apr 16, 2016
3
0
1,510
Hi, I bought 8Gb (4x2GB) of brand new (unbranded, but Elpida is visible on the chips) DDR2-800, unbuffered non-ECC to use in my newly-acquired Asus Crosshair II motherboard. The memory was sold as being suitable for AMD-processor motherboards only. The motherboard may be a bit old, but I was trying to find a cheap way of getting to run my Nvidia M2090, and surprisngly few cheap motherboards seem to allow the use of a graphics card with no monitor capability alongside the standard built-in graphics adapter, for double-precision computational fluid dynamics, for which at a budget price the M2090 still beats most things hands down.

None of the new memory sticks would even allow the motherboard to get as far as bios setup, and the LCD post screen (I thought it was a gimmick, but it turned out to be very useful) kept indicating it was stopping at varying points that pointed to a memory problem. The furthest it got was showing the ROG logo on the screen with 'press DEL to enter setup...', and then a pattern appeared overwriting specs on the screen, and it would boot no further. I've forgotten the exact message on the LCD post screen, but it indicated it was stuck at a memory check.

I found an old stick of 512MB DDR2-800 and it booted perfectly with that first time. I reset bios parameters to 'safe defaults', and tried each stick of the new ram again and it made no difference.

I sent CPU-Z prints to the seller when asked and they didn't suggest any parameter changes to make, but I'm reluctant to just return it and get a refund because it was really cheap memory - if it's necessary to sacrifice a bit of performance to get it to work reliably, it would be worth it. Although I'm experienced at building PCs (ahem.... for over 25 years), I've never actually had memory problems before or had to get into memory tuning. Are there any 'safer than safe default' settings I could change to try to get it to at least work, and then see what I could improve to bring the performance back up a bit? The bios is already the latest version

Thanks for any assistance

Mike
 
Solution
Check that you have the latest BIOS, it may help. My first thought though would be these were made for a PC manufacturer and may be proprietary to that manufacturer. Dell, HP, Compaq and others often uesd propretary DRAM and even some HDs so you had to go to them for upgrades and pay 2-3 times the going price for a normal set of DRAM or HD

Tradesman1

Legenda in Aeternum
Check that you have the latest BIOS, it may help. My first thought though would be these were made for a PC manufacturer and may be proprietary to that manufacturer. Dell, HP, Compaq and others often uesd propretary DRAM and even some HDs so you had to go to them for upgrades and pay 2-3 times the going price for a normal set of DRAM or HD
 
Solution

coolinventor

Commendable
Apr 16, 2016
3
0
1,510


Thanks for that thought - I'll ask if its vendor-specific. The bios is already checked though, as I mentioned. I will mention that when I took the RAM to a trusted local computer seller yesterday for advice he literally was unable to contain his laughter when I said I'd paid £14 for 8GB. But that is also why I'm keen to find a way to get it to work. I will try reducing the ram speed when my new, quality, PSU arrives, as my Alpine 600W PSU just blew up when driving about 400W. I'm just hoping it hasn't also blown the motherboard.
 

coolinventor

Commendable
Apr 16, 2016
3
0
1,510
I tried the following experiment which worked: Using the spare DDR2 ram I had, in the BIOS I set the memory speed to a forced speed of 667MHz instead of 'Auto', which was presumably 800. At that speed the budget memory booted and worked properly. The PC seemed to be going at a very pleasant clip. I booted with Memtest86 to test it and it ran through the whole set of tests and came out clean. So just that speed reduction made the complete difference. Still below the spec at which it was advertised, but at THAT price, I'm prepared to pay something for that amount of memory that is at least comparable in performance.