Should I buy new or used CPU for editing / gaming rig?

Mike Bracewell

Honorable
Sep 16, 2013
5
0
10,510
Hi Guy's, thanks in advance for your replies, and apologies if this seems a dumb question or been asked a gazillion times before!

I'm planning on building a new 1080p gaming/editing rig, but money is really, really tight at the moment.

So, after trolling the Web, I'm considering building a quad-core Xeon E5-based rig from old server parts (i love to make life difficult for myself!) instead of a going down the conventional - and way more expensive - I5-6600 route (I7 too pricey & AMDs a bit rubbish for video-editing. Basically, I want it mainly for 1080p editing with a bit of gaming on the side).

The thing that really bothers me (apart from the risk of buying duff parts, finding compatible hardware, and the sheer amount of dury-rigging), is how much life a 5-10 yo processor would have in it, once it's retired from commercial service.

I should imagine any CPU, running in a datacenter 24/7, will be well and truly knackered, after years of service and there would be a good chance it'll fail within a year or two of heavy overclocked gaming/ video rendering etc, especially one that found its way onto Ebay for £25!

I can't afford to replace the thing every 18 months or so, so this is a major concern.

Should I be worried or should "I take the plunge"?

What do you think?

Cheers Mike
 
Solution


The Xeons are basically built to last forever. That and the fact that they weren't overclocked makes them a very safe investment second hand.
The E5-2670 are very popular these days as they have a killer price/perf at around 60. While they wouldn't be the best of the...

Mike Bracewell

Honorable
Sep 16, 2013
5
0
10,510
Cheers, mate, for your great suggestion & for getting back so quickly. Unfortunately I live in the UK, & many US traders (except the biggies like Amazon) either don't ship over here or charge exorbitant shipping rates. In the UK, the E3 costs over £200 (over $300), the mboard £75 ($100), which is a bit steep.

Really all I wanted to know is if an ancient, old E5 would last any length of time if it was used for HD editing or just go "phut" after a 18 months ;)
 


The Xeons are basically built to last forever. That and the fact that they weren't overclocked makes them a very safe investment second hand.
The E5-2670 are very popular these days as they have a killer price/perf at around 60. While they wouldn't be the best of the best for gaming they are fantastic for rendering/editing. And putting two of those in a dual CPU board makes a MONSTER machine.
 
Solution