Can/How attaching SSD or HDD over USB corrupt OS/Cause Freezing and lockups?

Barty1884

Retired Moderator
Hi all,

Long story short, today I picked up a 120GB Kingston SSDNow V300 on Kiijiji locally for $5 CAD.

Anyway, the seller claimed this was bought new, but he was never able to install an OS to it.
For $5, I figured I'd give it a try.

I attached it via an external USB enclosure I have. Drive shows up inside Windows (so it was formatted/named at least!) - but it appears to be causing lockups/freezing while attached.
1. Disk Management wouldn't open while it was attached
2. Windows Explorer started 'not responding' when trying to explore the drive
3. Explorer.exe crashed (black screen in the background, browser sitting over top appeared unaffected.

Any thoughts/suggestions as to why this would happen?

This is not the first time this has happened to me - replacing an HDD with an SSD in my GF's kids laptop as the HDD appeared to be failing. Got his laptop all set up, and attached the HDD via (another) enclosure over USB3.0 and the same problems occurred - although that time, it appeared to impact my OS as, even when the USB was not attached, I was having freezing/lockup issues.

I didn't have the time/patience/effort at that time to diagnose the issue, and I just reinstalled Windows (my OS is pretty clean/thin at all times anyway, so no big deal). I had (probably wrongly) assumed the fact the drive had an OS installed on it, was conflicting in some way with my install.

As an FYI, at the time, my rig was 100% different - there's not a single component that remains, so that *should* rule out a hardware issue on the part of my rig.

The USB3.0 enclosure is also not the same one - although worth noting this enclosure worked perfectly the other day to migrate some info from a couple of old HDDs.

Anyway, any suggestions as to the cause &/or how to remedy this SSD? (The prior HDD is around somewhere too, so it would be nice if I could check the health of it too).
 

venom1245

Commendable
Jun 22, 2016
16
0
1,520
HI.
I have had this kind of issues sometimes, in my experience, i couldnt do anything :c all i could do was installing ubuntu on one of them, i think it was the less damaged one, so you may be able to instal an linux based OS, or check with a live cd if you can re-format it.
 

pingu_Z

Distinguished
Jun 21, 2008
21
0
18,520
use a live CD to zero write the drive, I have only ever seen that happen with SSD's that were once a part of a raid array then removed from said array. I don't know why but even with formatting the drives they behave oddly.
 

Barty1884

Retired Moderator
Thanks @BadActor, I can't believe I didn't think of that - always seems so much easier giving advice to others :lol:

Attached via SATA, detected in Disk Management & in Explorer. Was able to format in Disk Management.
Funnily enough, I put it back in the enclosure afterwards - attached via USB3, and the issue repeated itself. Rebooted & attached via USB2 (on a hunch), and no issues there!!

Interesting.

Anyway, that's not a bad purchase, all things considered. I've no need for the drive (at the moment) but should be a nice little upgrade for someone when the time comes - or part of a 'frankenrig' when I find suitable/cheap components.
 

Barty1884

Retired Moderator
Good call BA, I'll check that out. I've only ever used Samsung SSDs (personally), and ADATA, Silicon Power & Sandisks for others. This is the first Kingston drive overall - and I gather they're not particularly great. I'll see if a firmware update is available when I go to use the drive.
 
I've used a few of those drives now in older laptops that I didn't want to put a lot of money in to. They're cheap and faster than an HDD, but the sustained writes leave a lot to be desired. Never any trouble with any of them, though. Five bucks was a score.