Worthy upgrade from GTX 580 for FHD @ 60FPS - 1st Gen 1366 i7 Extreme

keeperos

Distinguished
Aug 17, 2007
98
0
18,630
My current PC is a 1st generation (socket 1366) i7 Extreme 975 @ 3.3GHz with 12GB triple-channel 1333 DDR3 on a Gigabyte G1.Sniper (X58/ICH10R chipset, 2 PCI Express 2.0 x16 slots + 1 x8 plus other goodies.
The OS is Windows 10 Pro x64.

My PSU is a modular Silverstone Strider ST1000-G Evolution (1000W @ 80 Plus Gold) so power supply is not an issue (although power-consumption obviously is).

While I know it is a fairly old platform, I have no plans of upgrading it for at least the next 1-2 years.

Currently I have it paired with a factory overclocked Asus GTX 580 w/1.5GB GDDR5 and while for MOST games it works fine, in certain AAA titles as well as poorly optimized ones (Carmageddon Reincarnation comes to mind) it is now starting to show its' age (I suspect the culprit primarily being the sub-2GB on-board memory rather than the GF110 chip itself) and I have been contemplating an upgrade.
I also have intermittently experienced GPU lockups and restarts on various occasions (usually it is just the driver that crashes and the GPU reboots, the PC stays online) perhaps due to the factory overclock.

My monitor is a 16x10 Samsung T240 at 1920x1200 which I also have no plans of upgrading.

Thus, I am looking for the optimal GPU for a best FHD@60FPS (well, 1920x1200, not 1080) experience that still isn't seriously bottlenecked by the rest of the PC and/or PCI-e slot. I will probably keep said card for at least the next 2-3 years (I got the 580 just when the 680 had been released).

What would you believe to be the card that makes the most sense from a performance, monetary and future-proofing standpoint?
 
Solution
You have almost the same build i did 7 years ago :p Ran a i7 950, asus R3E MB, 12GB ram, Silverston Strider 1000w PSu. Moved that build through dual 460's, 480's, 580's... moved the 580's over to a 2600k build for a few years then scrapped the whole build for the current one in my sig.

I would look a the new 1060 for an upgrade, i saw a large boost going from dual 580's to the 980 and the 1060 (according to some reviews) is on par or slightly better then a 980. If your slugging along with a 580 i think a 1060 will last a good few years.
You have almost the same build i did 7 years ago :p Ran a i7 950, asus R3E MB, 12GB ram, Silverston Strider 1000w PSu. Moved that build through dual 460's, 480's, 580's... moved the 580's over to a 2600k build for a few years then scrapped the whole build for the current one in my sig.

I would look a the new 1060 for an upgrade, i saw a large boost going from dual 580's to the 980 and the 1060 (according to some reviews) is on par or slightly better then a 980. If your slugging along with a 580 i think a 1060 will last a good few years.
 
Solution

keeperos

Distinguished
Aug 17, 2007
98
0
18,630
Oh yeah, forgot to mention, I already have a CoolerMaster Hyper 212 EVO, just for testing I was able to overclock the CPU to a rock-solid 4.2 GHz without touching any voltages but as I had to disable TurboBoost and HyperThreading I only saw minimal performance gains so after a (totally unrelated) BIOS crash and return to default I simply didn't bother again.

So, for EXACTLY the same amount of money I can get:
- An Asus GeForce GTX1060 6GB Turbo (90YV09R0-M0NA00)
- Various factory overclocked GTX970 4GB
- A Gigabyte Radeon RX 480 8GB (GV-RX480D5-8GD-B)

From the above comments it looks the 1060 being the superior choice, am I correct?
 

RobCrezz

Expert
Ambassador
Yeah with the 580 im sure you didnt see much improvement in FPS when overclocking the CPU, but it would be worthwhile for a newer faster GPU due to the potential for CPU bottlenecking.

I am also going to recommend the 1060, I just bought one and very happy with it.
 


OC'ing his 975 will get him a little more performance, I took my 950 up to 4.9ghz with a 24/7 OC of 4.7. Also had my 580's OC'd to 990/1960/2360 with a custom voltage bios.
 

TRENDING THREADS