Two computers can both connect to network except at port in study, one connects, other reports 'Media Disconnected'

dc_gator

Commendable
Aug 8, 2016
2
0
1,510
Hi folks, hope you can help solve an ethernet connection mystery I am having.

I have just built a new computer (mobo is Gigabyte Z170x UD5) and thought I might have a faulty motherboard because when I connected it to the port in the study, where my other working computer is, I got a 'Media Disconnected' message from ipconfig for both NICs. Updated bios, chipset and network drivers and still same message. Cable and port work fine in old computer, and I always get an instant network connection. On a lark, I lugged the computer, monitor, keyboard, etc. down to the basement and plugged it directly into the modem, and now the network connected fine on both NICs. So then I plugged it directly into the main router, also in basement, and again both NICs connected no problem. Took it to another room in the basement and plugged it into the port in that room, and everything was still fine (ethernet run from the router to port less than distance to the study, but more than 20 ft). Next plugged it into the Media Room port, a run equal to or longer than the run to the study (approx 50 feet), and again instant connection. Finally brought it back up to the study, where I would like it to reside, and 'Media Disconnected' report again. But the other computer, when plugged into the same port (and from where I am now typing this message) connects no problem. The two NICs look pristine, no dust, bent pins. The port in the wall has been taken out and examined (but not tested--I don't have a tester) and it too looks patent and clean. I have searched the googles for three days now and can't find anything like this having been reported. I am stumped. Any ideas?

To recap:
Old computer can connect to home network from all available ports with multiple available cables no problem.
New computer can connect to home network from all available ports with multiple cables WITH THE EXCEPTION OF the port located in the study, where the computer will ultimately live.
Things I have done that have had no impact.
Drivers and bios on new computer are up to date.
Changed the NICs configurations to 100 Mbs from Autoregulate.
Turned off WOL.
Tried to disable one or the other NICs, but the BIOS only allows the entire LAN Adapter to be disabled, which I take it would disable both NICs.

Thanks for any ideas, I am at a loss.
 
Solution
Just because a port works does not mean it really meets the connection standards. It can be as simple as a slightly loose connection on just 1 wire. Some devices are just more tolerant of a poor connection than others. The cost of the equipment to actually test jacks can pass data at certain rates is extremely costly. All you can do is first check that all the wires seem to be properly connected in the jack. You need to check both ends. After that all you can do is cut off a bit a wire on one or both ends and reterminate it and hope to get lucky and get a better connection.
Just because a port works does not mean it really meets the connection standards. It can be as simple as a slightly loose connection on just 1 wire. Some devices are just more tolerant of a poor connection than others. The cost of the equipment to actually test jacks can pass data at certain rates is extremely costly. All you can do is first check that all the wires seem to be properly connected in the jack. You need to check both ends. After that all you can do is cut off a bit a wire on one or both ends and reterminate it and hope to get lucky and get a better connection.
 
Solution
You have certainly diagnosed it down to bad wiring.

If you have termination tools I would go and just terminate the different ends of the cable (and try new patch cables).

The problem could still be the wire in the actual wall, but only an expensive network certifier would prove that.
 

dc_gator

Commendable
Aug 8, 2016
2
0
1,510
thanks bill001g and boosted1g, After posting I thought to myself the one thing I haven't done is check the port on the router itself, maybe it has gotten dirty or gone flaky or something, So I came down and unplugged the cable from the study and swapped it with another port. Still the 'Media Disconnect' message, but now it appeared on BOTH machines! Yeeaahh, I have no internet connection!! (weird, right!) So it looks like the terminus on the router side was flaky. Now if I can just find my crimping tool!

Thanks for helping me to rule out other issues!