I had the opposite with a XFX R390 that I upgraded to a 390x. With my old 390, I would get like 90-120 fps on High then Ultra was like 80-100. Not sure what your settings are in game? But theres a tab to decrease viewing distance? or GPU processing. I forget exactly what its called. Try that.
I5-6500
8gigs of DDR4
850w PSU.