Two Connected Routers vs Repeater?

kaloudis69

Commendable
Sep 15, 2016
2
0
1,510
I have an Arris modem/router (Main Router) in my family room. My kitchen is at the other end of the house where I always have a very weak wi-fi signal. The backyard never gets wi-fi from the Arris. Recently I purchased a TP-Link router (2nd Router) to put in the kitchen. I used a power line to connect the Main Router to the WAN port of the 2nd Router. Of course the 2nd Router now has a separate SSID and shows up as a separate wi-fi option, but now I can get great wi-fi signal in my kitchen and backyard by switching to the 2nd Router Wi-Fi when I'm in the kitchen. My iphone, ipad etc, switch automatically from the Main Router wi-fi to the 2nd Router wi-fi as I move around the house (most of the time anyway).

Recently I read an article and considered making the 2nd Router a Repeater so that essentially there will be only one wi-fi SSID in the house. My question is: The process of making the 2nd Router a repeater seems to be too complex to justify the change and I’m wondering: Will making the 2nd Router a Repeater provide any greater benefit than the set-up I have now? If so, why?
 
Solution
Wireless repeaters, which are *rarely* useful are used when you need to extend wireless range and do not have the option of making any direct connection between the devices (Ethernet, powerline, MOCA).

They cut your bandwidth in half unless you use multiple bands (which are not supported on a lot of devices).

They are pretty much the opposite of what you want for a home roaming set up. What you have is the best option. Good choices.

RealBeast

Titan
Moderator
I would leave it as you have it now.

Your roaming devices decide when to handoff from one wireless radio to another. You would need commercial equipment to set up a controller with wireless virtual networks to make the handoff seamless and effective.

Usually, for consumer equipment using different SSIDs on the main router and router set as an AP allow you to control which radio to connect with as opposed to letting the devices select, as they may not always select the strongest signal.
 

RealBeast

Titan
Moderator
Wireless repeaters, which are *rarely* useful are used when you need to extend wireless range and do not have the option of making any direct connection between the devices (Ethernet, powerline, MOCA).

They cut your bandwidth in half unless you use multiple bands (which are not supported on a lot of devices).

They are pretty much the opposite of what you want for a home roaming set up. What you have is the best option. Good choices.
 
Solution