Gtx 1070 vs r9 390 test results (Should I return the gtx 1070 and wait for vega?)

TheFinalEpic

Reputable
Nov 6, 2015
62
0
4,660
Today I bought the Gtx 1070 out of impulse, AMD is generally always better in long term of an investment but they always are slow as [watch your language] to the pack. Nvidia release better stuff quickly but guts their card after 1 year forcing you to update every year. I dislike both companies at this point but AMD has edge in DX 12 and Vulkan (which heavily uses Async compute). I wanted to wait for Vega but that could be as late as June 2017 at this point.

TEST RESULTS:

GTX 1070
Ashes of the Singularity

Crazy:
(DX12):
1440P: 43.4 FPS
1080P :51.1 FPS
(DX11):
1440P 44.1 FPS
1080P:51.4 FPS

Standard:
(DX12):
1440P: 71.0 FPS
1080P: 81.2 FPS
(DX11):
1440P: 67.6 FPS
1080P:71.5 FPS

Valley(DX11): Max settings
1440P:57.4 FPS/2401 Score
1080P: 90.9 FPS/3805 Score

Heaven (DX11): Tesellation Disabled
1440p: 95.8 FPS/2414 Score
1080P: 180.8 FPS/4553 Score

Witcher 3 (DX11) Ultra, Hairworks off.
1440P: 63FPS
1080P: 88 FPS



R9 390
Ashes of the Singularity

Crazy:
(DX12):
1440P: 35.5
1080P: 39.9
(DX11)
1440P: 31.5
1080P: 35.6

Standard:
(DX12):
1440P: 52.5
1080P: 65.3
(DX11):
1440P: 47.0
1080P: 52.8

Valley (DX11): Max Settings
1440P: 40.7 FPS, 1702 Score
1080P 65.1 FPS, 2723 Score

Heaven (DX11): Tesselation Disabled
1440P: 54.1 FPS, 1362 Score
1080P: 100.2 FPS, 2523 Score

Witcher 3 (DX11) Ultra, Hairworks Off.
1440P: 42 FPS
1080P: 58 FPS


Complete PC Set up:
http://pcpartpicker.com/list/6d4jGf
TLDR: i7 4790k, 1.33 volt 4.7ghz overclock, 32 gb 1866 mmhz DDR3 Ram.
Monitor: MG279Q, 1440p, 144hz, IPS, Freesync (60 to 144hz sync range)

Picture of both cards:
(GTX 1070 On the Left,R9 390 on the right.)
http://imgur.com/cSu98Sb



Vega most likely won't be a huge performance leap to gtx 1070 and gtx 1080. (Fury X was touted as going to be the most powerful graphic card in the world triumphing over the Titan X, when released, 4 GB limited memory and was no where near TItan X, Nvidia has this issue also, Pascal last year was hyped up to have lower end have GGR5X memory and upper end have HBM2 memory with 10x more compute power than Maxwell, Reality? No HBM2 on high end, GGDR5x is high end, and to the Asian CEO, Pascal does not have 10X compute power than Maxwell, its a maxwell architecture with a die shrink and runs at 2X higher MHZ Rx 480 was hyped up as a gtx 980ti killer at a 200-300 dollar price range with HBM2. Reality? No HBM2 and RX 480 is basically a gtx 1060, r9 390, and gtx 970, seriously, they're all 1-2 FPS within one another in DX11 and DX12.

TLDR: Both sides fail expectation the past 2 years. I'm treating upcoming graphic card releases with lessons learned from No Man Sky (ty god i didn't buy it though). Most hyped things are probably just pretty meh.


Back to the topic at hand though, from these test results do you think I should keep gtx 1070 for dx 11 and dx12 gaming? or just wait for Vega because Nvidia can't do Async compute for their life (Vulkan and DX12, the future API, uses Async computing). But AMD is slow as fuck to release shit and most likely won't deliver even though all their graphic card age well.



 

hdmark

Distinguished
Feb 16, 2015
1,367
0
19,660
1- what do you mean invidia guts their cards after a year?
2- youre pretty salty :p
3- just keep the invidia card. if you have the money to impulse buy the 1070, keep it till vega comes out and then revisit it. you can also sell the 1070 on ebay
 

TheFinalEpic

Reputable
Nov 6, 2015
62
0
4,660


I've had the 460, 670 and 760, their performance was garbage after 1 year....

And yes I am salty. I'm frustrated with both AMD and Nvidia. I see both pros and cons to both companies and ugh.
 

Embra

Distinguished
If you are not happy with the performance increase for $$ spent, return it. Vega 10 sounds like it will be out before Xmas. It will be a strong card and if nothing else lower the prices of the 1080 possibly.
 

TheFinalEpic

Reputable
Nov 6, 2015
62
0
4,660


I just want 1070 performance but for DX12 which both sides doesn't have atm. I just want to buy one card that will last 4-5 years(I just hate upgrading, I rather just buy a good card and be set)
 

TRENDING THREADS