Corsair H55 vs aircooling

Solution
Between those coolers the h55 will be; between something like a v8GTS, or a Noctua NHD14, the air coolers edge out a victory. Those air coolers however, do have the added bonus of being way more reliable than the H55 given that they only have one moving part, and can still function if that moving part fails for a time. The H55 has the obvious bonus of more effective cooling.

genthug

Honorable
Between those coolers the h55 will be; between something like a v8GTS, or a Noctua NHD14, the air coolers edge out a victory. Those air coolers however, do have the added bonus of being way more reliable than the H55 given that they only have one moving part, and can still function if that moving part fails for a time. The H55 has the obvious bonus of more effective cooling.
 
Solution
In terms of value for money, an air cooler is always better. A water cooler obviously looks better and you have the kudos of saying that you have water cooling as well, but there's an increased risk in terms of reliability.

A big advantage of water coolers is that they can bring high temperatures back down far quicker than air coolers.

Between the coolers you've chosen, they all offer much the same performance. If it's available in your country, get a Cryorig H7; it's better than all of them.