Can Crossfire or PCI-E damage BOTH Cards?

Tom72468

Reputable
Mar 26, 2016
54
0
4,540
1st Setup: ASUS P6T SE, i7 920, CM850M Corsair PSU, 6GB RAM.
2nd Setup: ASUS P7P55-M, i3 550, 750TX Corsair PSU, 8GB RAM.

Originally, I bought a 2nd MSI R6970 Lightning for the 1st setup, and it ran fine in Crossfire (Even in 1 PCI-E x16 slot, and 1 x4 slot). Ran fine for about a week. Then quick, random crashes under load. The factory R6970's are OC'd at 940 MHz Clock. Tried upping the PSU from 750 to 850. Same thing. Tried removing one card. Tried swapping cards. Tried different PCI-E slot (x16 & x4). Tried 5 different drivers, tried clean install of Windows. Newest BIOS installed. All Diagnostics lights on GPU are lit and steady. EVERYTHING WAS FINE IN THE BEGINNING WITH NO OTHER HARDWARE, OR SOFTWARE INSTALLED. Also have a higher end surge protector connected to a redundant surge protector.

I had to 'underclock' cards to 880 core to be stable.
SOOOOO. I built the 2nd setup (Only 1 PCI-E slot). Both cards do EXACTLY THE SAME THING. Swapped Cards, swapped PSU's, even swapped memory! Switched BIOS switch on GPU. Again a clean install of Windows.

BOTH cards are behaving EXACTLY the same way in MANY different configurations. I HAVE TO UNDERCLOCK THEM to be stable under load..
.
My question is this...Is it possible that one card went bad, or is starting to, and damaged the other either through the MB, or the crossfire connection? MSI & ASUS ARE OF ZERO HELP!!!!!

p.s. Nothing was ever overclocked and temps on CPU and/or GPU NEVER exceed 68 degrees.

 
Solution
It is unlikely that using crossfire would damage the video cards, but from what you wrote, it is the only explanation really. When they are running in crossfire, the GPU usage is usually a bit lower, since the scaling is not perfectly linear.

The only thing you didn't try is the video cards' BIOS. It is unlikely to be corrupt, but it's not impossible. It's the only thing I can think of.

PhysX_HW

Distinguished
It is unlikely that using crossfire would damage the video cards, but from what you wrote, it is the only explanation really. When they are running in crossfire, the GPU usage is usually a bit lower, since the scaling is not perfectly linear.

The only thing you didn't try is the video cards' BIOS. It is unlikely to be corrupt, but it's not impossible. It's the only thing I can think of.
 
Solution

Tom72468

Reputable
Mar 26, 2016
54
0
4,540


Actually, the cards have dual BIOS's, so I tried that. Here it is 8 1/2 months later and NO ONE can help. Thanks for trying...They're still working, yet still behaving the same...880. NOT 940. No degradation at all.